Senator Rand Paul suggested a crackdown on individuals, asserting that the right to free speech isn’t absolute due to morals or conduct clauses in contracts. This call to action, juxtaposed with the recent assassination of Charlie Kirk, has spurred an ironic shift among right-wing figures, who are now attacking free speech and civil liberties. Leading figures like JD Vance and others are engaging in doxing campaigns and advocating for consequences for those expressing dissenting opinions. These actions highlight a stark hypocrisy, particularly given the past criticisms of others policing speech.
Read More
The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) has controversially declared that filming and posting videos of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents constitutes “violence” and has threatened potential charges against those who record immigration raids, despite First Amendment protections. While the First Amendment generally protects the right to record law enforcement activities in public, the DHS’s stance has drawn criticism. This is further highlighted by incidents, such as the June arrest and detention of a PhD student who was documenting an ICE raid, who claims he was attacked by agents. The ACLU of Illinois has since clarified that recording ICE activity in public is a protected right and encourages people to do so safely.
Read More
A bill introduced in the House of Representatives has raised concerns among free speech advocates. The legislation could potentially grant the Secretary of State the authority to revoke U.S. passports without due process, based on an individual’s perceived support for designated foreign terrorist organizations. Critics argue this would allow the Secretary of State to act as judge, jury, and executioner, especially considering previous instances of visa revocations based on political views. The bill’s language mirrors provisions from previous legislative attempts, raising further concerns about the potential for thought policing and the targeting of protected speech.
Read More
Following the death of conservative influencer Charlie Kirk, Florida Education Commissioner Anastasios Kamoutsas announced an investigation into educators who made offensive online comments about the incident. Certified educators are bound by ethical guidelines, and violations could lead to revocation of their teaching certificates. Kamoutsas emphasized that First Amendment rights do not supersede professional duties, and public comments that undermine trust with students and families are unacceptable. Additionally, Lake County Commissioner Anthony Sabatini is proposing to rename a major roadway in honor of Kirk.
Read More
The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) under the Trump administration is claiming that the act of filming ICE agents and posting these videos online constitutes “violence.” DHS officials argue that such actions are “doxing” and will be prosecuted. This stance follows DHS Secretary Kristi Noem’s expanded definition of violence to include any action that threatens DHS agents, including videotaping. Civil rights experts, however, contend that this interpretation contradicts First Amendment rights, and may lack factual basis. Despite these concerns, DHS has a large budget and has seen an increase in reported rights violations in immigration detention facilities.
Read More
On Sunday, law enforcement removed the White House peace vigil, a protest that had been in place for over four decades, following President Trump’s order to clear homeless encampments. Officials justified the removal by mislabeling the vigil as a shelter, despite it being protected by the First Amendment. The White House confirmed the removal, citing it as a hazard to visitors and part of the administration’s federal takeover of policing in the city. The vigil, established in 1981 to promote nuclear disarmament, is considered the longest continuous anti-war protest in U.S. history.
Read More
The Republican Party of Texas (RPT) has filed a lawsuit in U.S. District Court alleging that the state’s open primary system infringes upon its First Amendment rights. The lawsuit contests the decades-long practice of allowing any registered Texas voter to participate in either party’s primary, provided they pledge not to vote in the opposing party’s primary. The RPT argues the current system enables crossover voting, potentially influencing Republican primary outcomes. Citing specific examples, including the 2024 primary runoff for Rep. Dade Phelan, the party claims this system allows non-Republicans to strategically vote in Republican primaries, undermining its ability to select its nominees.
Read More
In a recent ruling, a federal judge invalidated the Trump administration’s freeze of $2.2 billion in grant funds to Harvard University. The judge determined the funding freeze was an illegal and ideologically motivated action targeting universities. The court found that the administration’s focus on antisemitism served as a pretext for imposing demands that violated First Amendment protections. The court’s decision vacated the freeze orders and barred their enforcement, though the White House has announced plans to appeal.
Read More
Nathalie Rose Jones, arrested in August for allegedly threatening President Trump online, had charges against her refused by a grand jury in Washington D.C., according to her attorney. Judge Jeb Boasberg released Jones from GPS monitoring after she was initially detained, disagreeing with prosecutors who argued she made violent threats. Jones allegedly posted threatening messages online, including a Facebook post and an email, leading to her arrest when she traveled to D.C. for a protest. The U.S. Attorney’s office criticized the grand jury’s decision, suggesting it was politically motivated, and noted difficulties in obtaining indictments in other cases.
Read More
Following a protest against ICE, former army sergeant Bajun Mavalwalla II was arrested and charged with conspiracy, sparking concern among legal experts. The charges are viewed as an escalation in attacks on First Amendment rights and a potential test case for limiting protest activities. Mavalwalla, a veteran with a distinguished service record, faces a potential six-year prison sentence. His arrest has raised questions about selective prosecution and the lengths the Trump administration will go to suppress dissent.
Read More
John Q. Hosedrinker