First Amendment

Michigan School Bans Missionaries from Lunchtime After Complaint

Following a complaint from the Freedom From Religion Foundation, Fremont Public Schools in Michigan will no longer permit missionaries on school grounds during lunch. The foundation, which advocates for the separation of church and state, cited instances where missionaries attempted to proselytize to students and another organization distributed permission slips for students to receive Bibles. The district’s superintendent confirmed that both religious outreach practices will cease, addressing concerns that these activities violated the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment by giving religious groups preferential access to students.

Read More

Firefighter Fired for Charlie Kirk Comments Receives Settlement

A firefighter in Polk City, Iowa, who was terminated for her online comments made after the killing of conservative activist Charlie Kirk, has received a significant settlement. The case highlights a recurring theme where public employees disciplined for their off-duty speech regarding Kirk’s death have found legal recourse, often resulting in financial payouts from their employers. This particular firefighter, Alissa Furry, was let go after posting on her private Facebook page in a manner that was perceived as lacking sympathy for Kirk’s passing.

Furry’s termination stemmed from several posts, including a statement indicating she chose “not to celebrate” Kirk’s death but also “not be sad,” and a meme that drew a parallel between an assassination at a college and a high school shooting.… Continue reading

First Amendment Protects Universities From Florida’s Stop WOKE Act

A federal appeals court has struck down key provisions of Florida’s Stop WOKE Act, ruling that the state cannot mandate its preferred ideology in educational institutions or workplaces. The court emphasized that government censorship of conversations is incompatible with the First Amendment, especially in academic settings. While acknowledging that the state may have valid concerns about certain ideologies, the decision asserts that the government cannot intervene in ideological battles by banning or promoting specific beliefs. Instead, the court champions open debate and the marketplace of ideas as the appropriate means for addressing differing viewpoints.

Read More

Appeals Judges Rule Florida Ban on College “Woke” Lessons Unconstitutional

A panel of Eleventh Circuit judges has ruled that Florida’s “anti-woke” restrictions on university instruction regarding race and gender violate professors’ First Amendment rights. This decision upholds a lower court’s finding, asserting that while states can shape university curricula, they cannot arbitrarily restrict viewpoints they deem objectionable. The challenged law, known as the Stop WOKE Act, had banned the teaching of concepts related to critical race theory, white privilege, and affirmative action. The divided 2-1 panel, with a Trump-appointed judge dissenting, found these restrictions overstepped constitutional boundaries.

Read More

ICE Compared to Nazis, Agency Tracks Down Critic on Vacation

Following federal shootings, David Streever emailed acting ICE Director Todd Lyons with harsh criticism, for which ICE agents later attempted to serve him a warning notice for potentially violating federal law. The notice claimed Streever’s email may have violated statutes against threatening federal officials or using their personal information to incite violence, despite the email containing no such threats. Streever is now suing, alleging the government is violating his First Amendment rights by attempting to silence and intimidate critics through these warning notices. This tactic mirrors a broader trend of the Trump administration labeling protected speech as threatening to suppress public backlash against immigration enforcement.

Read More

Man Sues ICE After Officers Visit Home Over Critical Email

An upstate New York citizen is suing U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, alleging the agency violated his First Amendment rights by sending federal officers to his home to deliver a warning about an email he sent to the agency’s former acting director. The email, sent after an ICE officer fatally shot a protester, contained strong criticisms of the director and was deemed a threat by ICE. The lawsuit contends that such political speech is protected under the First Amendment, and points to a similar incident involving another upstate New York resident who received a federal warning after criticizing ICE online.

Read More

Georgia Teacher Awarded $300K Settlement Over Charlie Kirk Social Media Post

The Oglethorpe County School District has settled a lawsuit with a former Georgia teacher of the year finalist for nearly $300,000. The teacher, Michelle Mickens, had sued the district for violating her First Amendment rights after she was pressured to resign for a social media post quoting conservative activist Charlie Kirk. The settlement, which includes emotional distress damages and attorney’s fees, requires Mickens to resign and not seek future employment with the district, while the district agreed to provide a positive reference. This resolution comes amidst a wave of similar legal challenges nationwide where educators have alleged free speech violations over controversial social media activity.

Read More

Judge Rules ‘Trump Raped Little Girls’ Signs Protected Speech

A federal judge has permanently blocked the Trump administration from revoking permits for protesters displaying “8647” flags and signs near the National Mall. The administration had argued the numerical slogan constituted an incitement to violence, but the court found it was a protected form of political speech calling for the President’s impeachment. The judge also ruled that other signs addressing alleged sexual misconduct were not obscene and were likewise protected under the First Amendment. This ruling upholds the protesters’ right to engage in core political speech in a public forum.

Read More

Protester’s Darth Vader Theme Lawsuit Settled After First Amendment Claim

The District of Columbia has reached an undisclosed financial settlement with Sam O’Hara, who alleged unlawful detention by police for playing Darth Vader’s theme song on his phone. O’Hara had been protesting a federal law-enforcement surge in the capital and claimed violations of his First and Fourth Amendment rights. This agreement resolves O’Hara’s claims against the district and four police officers, though his related claims against an Ohio National Guard member are still pending. The ACLU described the settlement amount as “significant” and stated O’Hara is pleased with the terms.

Read More