First Amendment

Sandwich Thrower Acquitted of Assault in Washington Case

AP News reports that Sean Charles Dunn, a former Justice Department employee, was found not guilty of assault after throwing a sandwich at a federal agent during the Trump administration’s law enforcement surge in Washington. The viral video of the incident made Dunn a symbol of resistance. Dunn’s defense argued the sandwich toss was a harmless gesture of protest protected by the First Amendment. Prosecutors faced a setback in the case, mirroring broader pushback against the Justice Department’s handling of surge-related criminal cases.

Read More

DC Police Sued After Arresting Man for Darth Vader Theme Protest

A DC resident, Sam O’Hara, has filed a lawsuit against DC Metro police officers after being arrested for playing Darth Vader’s theme music near National Guard troops. O’Hara was protesting the troops’ presence in the city by recording them and playing “The Imperial March,” which the ACLU lawyers argue is a form of protected expression. Despite not impeding the troops or engaging in any threatening behavior, O’Hara was arrested after an Ohio National Guard member complained about the satirical protest. The officers then handcuffed and detained O’Hara, but he was eventually released when officials realized there was no legal basis for his arrest.

Read More

Tennessee Drops Charges Against Man Who Posted Trump Meme, Sparks Lawsuit Talk

Charges against Larry Bushart, who was jailed for over a month for a Trump meme, were unexpectedly dropped Wednesday. Bushart was arrested for threatening mass violence at a school because the meme, which quoted Trump, was misinterpreted as a threat to shoot up Perry County High School. The dismissal occurred after a NewsChannel 5 interview revealed investigators knew the meme referred to an Iowa shooting, not the local school. Furthermore, new video footage raised questions about the sheriff’s initial account of the encounter, ultimately leading to the nolle prosequi.

Read More

Trump DOJ Indicts Congressional Candidate for Protesting ICE; Faces Prison

The House leader has attempted to discredit the “No Kings” protests, falsely portraying them as violent to deflect criticism of his own failures. Despite these claims, the protests have largely focused on First Amendment rights and opposition to specific policies, including those related to immigration and healthcare. Simultaneously, the leader seems intent on prolonging the government shutdown, sending representatives home and dismissing negotiations as futile while blaming Democrats for the impasse.

Read More

Broadview ICE Protesters, Including Candidate, Face Federal Conspiracy Charges

The Department of Justice has filed federal conspiracy charges against congressional candidate Kat Abughazaleh and five others related to a protest outside the Broadview ICE facility last month. The indictment alleges the group conspired to impede or injure federal officers during a September 26th protest, where they allegedly surrounded a government vehicle. Other protesters also face individual charges of assault and resisting officers. The accused, including Cook County board and Oak Park officials, are fighting the charges, calling them an attempt to stifle protest and an attack on First Amendment rights.

Read More

D.C. Man Sues After Arrest for “Star Wars” Protest of National Guard

A Washington, D.C. resident is suing after being detained while protesting the National Guard deployment, alleging violations of his rights. The individual, Sam O’Hara, played “The Imperial March” from “Star Wars” as a form of protest and was subsequently detained by D.C. police after a sergeant from the Ohio National Guard contacted them. The lawsuit, filed in federal court, claims violations of the First and Fourth Amendments, as well as false arrest and battery, naming the sergeant, several D.C. officers, and the District of Columbia as defendants. This case is unfolding amidst other legal battles concerning deployments under the previous administration.

Read More

DC Man Sues After Arrest for Playing Darth Vader Theme at Troops

A Washington D.C. resident is suing local police officers, a member of the Ohio National Guard, and the District of Columbia after being detained while protesting the Trump administration’s deployment of National Guard troops. The plaintiff, Sam O’Hara, was playing Darth Vader’s theme song from Star Wars while following a National Guard patrol, actions he shared on TikTok. The lawsuit alleges that his First and Fourth Amendment rights were violated and that the arrest constituted false arrest, imprisonment, and battery. O’Hara seeks compensatory damages, claiming the actions of the military and law enforcement were unconstitutional.

Read More

Iowa Teacher Wins Lawsuit Over Kirk-Related Social Media Posts

A judge has issued a temporary restraining order preventing the Creston Community School District from firing a teacher. This order prohibits the district from taking adverse employment actions against Melissa Crook based on her social media comments regarding Charlie Kirk. However, the judge denied Crook’s request to be removed from administrative leave, meaning she will not be returning to the classroom at this time. The lawsuit was filed after Crook was placed on administrative leave and recommended for termination following her controversial post. Further court proceedings are scheduled for October 31st, 2025.

Read More

Banned Race and Gender Books Return to Military Base School Libraries

A federal judge has ruled that the Department of Defense must return books about race and gender to school libraries on military bases after the removal of nearly 600 books sparked a lawsuit. The students, children of active-duty service members, alleged their First Amendment rights were violated due to the removal of books covering topics such as sexual identity and racism. The American Civil Liberties Union filed a motion on behalf of the families, arguing the removals stemmed from partisan motivations related to executive orders prohibiting materials promoting “gender ideology and discriminatory equity ideology” and guidance issued by the Secretary of Defense. Judge Patricia Tolliver Giles sided with the students, citing “improper partisan motivation” and ordering the restoration of the removed materials.

Read More

IU Fires Student Paper Advisor After Refusal to Censor News

Tensions have arisen between Indiana University and its student newspaper, the *Indiana Daily Student*, resulting in the elimination of print editions and the firing of its faculty advisor, Jim Rodenbush. The advisor was terminated for refusing to censor the homecoming edition, sparking concerns about censorship and First Amendment rights. The university claims the shift from print is a financial decision, yet the move has drawn criticism from advocates for student media, alumni, and high-profile figures. The *Daily Student* continues to publish online, but the recent events have led to accusations of administrative overreach and attempts to control the paper’s editorial content.

Read More