By John Q. Hosedrinker 
During a chaotic bull run at Spain’s San Fermin festival on Saturday, one runner sustained a facial goring, while twelve others required medical attention for various injuries. The event saw six bulls and steers charging through dense crowds along the narrow street course, resulting in numerous knockdowns and pileups. Despite the danger, many runners appeared unaware of the bulls’ proximity, with some simply being shoved aside rather than gored. This incident marks the fifth run of the eight-day festival, which gained international recognition following Ernest Hemingway’s novel “The Sun Also Rises.”
Read the original article here
It’s truly shocking, and perhaps sadly predictable, that yet another runner has been gored in the face at Spain’s San Fermin bull run festival. This event, which draws international attention, has a long history, with its global fame significantly boosted a century ago by Ernest Hemingway’s novel, “The Sun Also Rises.” While the festival has a rich cultural tapestry, the inherent danger of the running of the bulls is undeniable, with gorings and broken bones being a frequent, albeit unfortunate, consequence.
The origins of this tradition stretch back to the Middle Ages, when bulls were herded through the city. By the 16th century, young men and butchers began to run alongside them, a practice that evolved into the current 848.6-meter track established in the late 18th century. This historical context, however, does little to soften the blow of seeing someone injured, particularly in such a direct and violent manner.
The sentiment expressed by many is that it’s difficult to muster sympathy for those who willingly participate in an activity so clearly fraught with peril. The prevailing view is that these participants, often novices and foreign tourists alongside experienced locals, are knowingly putting themselves in harm’s way. The phrase “play stupid games, win stupid prizes” echoes this sentiment, suggesting that the consequences are a direct result of foolish choices. It’s hard to escape the feeling that these runners have, in essence, “fucked around with a pissed off and aggressive animal four times their size and found out.”
There’s a strong undercurrent of concern for the animals involved. Many people express that their primary worry is for the bulls, hoping they are unharmed, and they strongly advocate for an end to what they perceive as barbaric and cruel traditions. The idea that these animals are forced into such situations for human amusement is deeply troubling to many, leading to the pointed observation that the bulls might view it as “The Chasing of The Idiots.”
Indeed, the psychological motivations behind participating in such dangerous events are questioned. While some might seek an adrenaline rush akin to watching a high-stakes race with the potential for a crash, the reality for the participants is far more visceral and potentially devastating. The excitement of “near-death” experiences is acknowledged, but the stark reality of their consequences often takes a backseat in the allure of the event.
The contrast between the runner’s injury and the fate of the bulls is stark. The bulls that participate in the morning runs are later destined for the bullring, where they are ultimately killed. This grim reality, often obscured by the festive atmosphere, is a significant point of contention for those who oppose the tradition. The event is described by some as a “Catholic veiled murder Mardi Gras,” highlighting the dissonance between its cultural facade and its violent core.
It’s noteworthy that many Spaniards themselves are reportedly against these cruel traditions, suggesting that the practice is not universally embraced within the country. The focus often shifts to the suffering of the bulls, described as being “drugged, cornered, tormented, stabbed with swords, and then slaughtered for the amusement of the Spaniards,” a fate that pales in comparison to the runner’s injury.
The recurring nature of these incidents begs the question of why they continue to make headlines. The simple answer, as many point out, is that people are willingly engaging with immense danger. The risk-reward calculus for many participants seems wildly skewed, with the potential for a horrific injury often outweighing any perceived benefit. The notion that one must “accept a few face gores in order to have the freedom to have Spain’s San Fermin bill run Festival” is a cynical, yet perhaps accurate, reflection of the perceived justification for its continuation.
Ultimately, the injury serves as a stark reminder of the inherent dangers of the San Fermin festival. While it may be a deeply ingrained cultural event, the ethical implications and the undeniable risks to both humans and animals remain a significant point of discussion and condemnation for many observers around the world. The hope for a less violent alternative, like a cheese-rolling competition, highlights a desire for traditions that prioritize safety and animal welfare over spectacle and risk.