By John Q. Hosedrinker 
An 18-month-old toddler, Vincent Lorenzo Fiordilino, was mistakenly pronounced dead at a hospital on Super Bowl Sunday after nearly drowning in his family’s pool. Six hours later, he was discovered breathing in the hospital morgue, leading to an investigation by the Maricopa County Attorney’s Office. The Gilbert Police Department recommended child abuse charges against the parents, who allegedly admitted to smoking marijuana earlier that day, potentially impairing their awareness of the child wandering off. Mercy Gilbert Medical Center is conducting its own internal investigation into the circumstances, including the actions of the doctor who pronounced the child dead while he was still showing signs of life.
Read the original article here
An Arizona toddler, tragically declared dead, was discovered alive in the hospital morgue, a bewildering turn of events that has ignited a firestorm of concern and disbelief. The initial pronouncement of death came from a doctor identified in police reports as A. Toosi. When questioned about his decision to declare the child deceased while the toddler was still exhibiting signs of life, the doctor reportedly invoked his authority. “Please do your thing and let me do my thing,” he is quoted as saying, adding, “I went to medical school for a reason.” This statement has been met with considerable skepticism, as the outcome clearly suggests that the doctor did not adequately perform his duties.
The harrowing experience for the toddler’s parents and the attending police officers began after the initial declaration of death. Despite the pronouncement, both the parents and law enforcement personnel present in the emergency room noted that the child still appeared to be gasping for breath. This unsettling observation persisted, with a detective reporting hearing another audible gasp around 7:18 p.m. as hospital staff prepared to move the child from the trauma room to the “cold room,” the hospital’s morgue, which is kept at a chilling 36 to 39 degrees Fahrenheit.
The situation grew even more disturbing when the same detective returned an hour later to photograph the body. He reported observing what appeared to be another gasp or release of air. In response to these continued signs of life, a nurse reportedly explained that the phenomena were due to “agonal breathing,” a reflex caused by compressions, oxygen, and potential pressure from family members during farewells. Despite these observable signs of life and the nurse’s explanation, the doctor’s initial declaration of death stood.
Adding another layer of complexity and heartbreak to the narrative, the department has recommended that the parents be charged with child abuse. According to a police report, the parents may have been unaware of their son wandering to the pool while they were preoccupied, potentially due to their state of mind being affected by marijuana or other substances. Both parents reportedly admitted to smoking marijuana on the morning of the incident. This raises questions about parental responsibility and the circumstances leading up to the near-fatal drowning.
The concept of agonal breathing itself has become a focal point of discussion. It is described as a reflex that can occur when the brain is still active despite the body’s systems shutting down. While it can resemble gasping, it is not considered a sign of consciousness or recovery. However, the crucial point of contention remains whether it is appropriate to declare someone dead while these involuntary reflexes are still occurring, especially when multiple observers noted what appeared to be continued signs of life. The idea that a child was declared dead, then transported to a cold room, and still exhibiting signs of life is deeply troubling.
The doctor’s assertion of having gone to medical school “for a reason” has been met with sharp criticism. Many are questioning the competency of the physician, suggesting that understanding the difference between life and death, particularly in the context of apparent breathing, should be a fundamental skill. There are serious concerns about the doctor’s judgment and whether they should continue practicing medicine. Some commenters have even jokingly suggested that the doctor might have graduated from a less reputable institution, highlighting the severity of the perceived medical error.
The “Lazarus phenomenon,” a term used to describe rare instances where individuals declared dead return to life, has been brought up in discussions. While these occurrences are not fully understood, they underscore the possibility of misinterpretation of vital signs, especially in critical situations. The experience for the child, regardless of the outcome, is undoubtedly traumatic. The prospect of being left breathing in a cold morgue for over an hour, potentially experiencing prolonged agony and fear, is a chilling thought that many find difficult to process.
The potential legal ramifications for both the doctor and the parents are significant. While the doctor faces scrutiny over their medical competency and potential negligence, the parents are under investigation for child abuse. The extent to which drug use influenced their ability to supervise their child is a key factor in the investigation. The challenge for law enforcement will be to definitively prove impairment and its direct link to the incident.
Beyond the immediate crisis, the long-term impact on the toddler is a significant concern. Reports indicate that the child is now ventilator-dependent, with an uncertain prognosis for recovery. This adds another layer of tragedy to an already devastating situation. The question of what happens next for the child, including potential placement in foster care, is also a somber consideration, with hopes for a better future and a loving family. The story serves as a stark reminder of the fragility of life and the critical importance of meticulous medical judgment and responsible parenting. The narrative, filled with the astonishing revelation of a living child found in a morgue, continues to provoke shock, anger, and a profound sense of empathy for all involved.