By John Q. Hosedrinker 
On Thursday, four Bay Area locations of Blue Bottle coffee voted to unionize, joining the growing trend of barista organizing across the U.S. The workers, who voted 22 to 5 in favor of joining the Blue Bottle Independent Union, aim to secure better benefits and higher wages to address the high cost of living. This independent union, which previously unionized six locations in the Boston area, is focused on maintaining flexibility and control. The union drive, announced in June, highlights concerns regarding benefits, wages, and transparency in coffee sourcing.
Read the original article here
Blue Bottle coffee workers at four California stores vote to join a union, and it’s definitely stirring up a lot of thoughts. It’s easy to imagine folks on both sides having strong opinions, but at the core, this is about workers seeking a better deal. Let’s be honest, the world of coffee shops isn’t always sunshine and rainbows.
The initial reaction often focuses on the ownership, and in this case, it’s Nestlé. Now, it’s probably no surprise that some people aren’t big fans of large corporations, especially when it comes to worker’s rights. The common narrative is that unions are bad for business, potentially leading to higher prices or even store closures. There are also people who assume that the union leaders make “big bucks”.
However, there’s another side of the story. It’s about workers wanting basic things: a living wage, respect from their employer, benefits that offer some security, and time off. These aren’t unreasonable requests for anyone putting in full-time hours. If a company can’t meet these needs, unions can provide leverage. The alternative for the company is dealing with constant turnover. The details matter and anecdotes about specific union experiences are a good way to ground the conversation. For example, one person mentions their dad’s union, with low dues, affordable health plans, generous vacation time, and fair pay for skilled work. That’s the experience of a well-run union.
Then, there’s the argument that coffee shop unions lack “teeth” compared to trade unions. The concern is that coffee workers could be easily replaced during a strike. But unionization in coffee shops is not about the ability to shut down an entire industry. It’s about the power of collective bargaining, creating better conditions for everyone in the workplace, and improving quality of life. It is about respect and fairness. And in a competitive labor market, if a union can offer better wages, benefits, and working conditions, they will attract and retain staff.
Some individuals mention a 50-cent raise and that it can more than make up for the dues. It highlights a practical perspective: unions can provide financial benefits that outweigh the costs. It’s a real-world consideration that resonates with workers on the ground.
The concept of a “Union Brewed” branding or even the idea of a visible symbol for non-union labor sparks an interesting discussion about consumer awareness and support. The idea of having some kind of indicator on a cup highlights the importance of knowing where your product comes from and the conditions of its production. The consumer may then make decisions based on their own values and priorities.
There are the stories from the people who have been in union environments. In the case that was provided, there’s a teacher, who was in a union district and now works in a public charter school. The teacher’s experience offers a direct comparison. The union job offered a much better salary. That person’s story underscores a point that’s often overlooked: unions don’t just benefit their members; they can raise wages for everyone. They help to improve the working conditions in an industry, creating a more fair and equitable environment for all. This is a powerful example of how unions can impact individual lives.
Ultimately, the vote by Blue Bottle workers is a reflection of the broader conversation happening across the country, and the discussion includes many different and important views on the role of unions, worker’s rights, and the future of work.