The Supreme Court unanimously reversed a lower court ruling dismissing a lawsuit against the federal government stemming from a wrongful FBI raid. The Court found the lower court incorrectly applied the Supremacy Clause, clarifying that a federal law allows lawsuits based on state tort law in cases like this. The case, involving an Atlanta family traumatized by a 2017 raid, will now proceed, allowing the 11th Circuit to consider the government’s liability for law enforcement’s mistakes. This decision potentially broadens legal avenues for accountability in cases of mistaken police raids.
Read More
The Supreme Court unanimously ruled to allow the Martin family’s lawsuit against the FBI to proceed, reversing lower court decisions that had dismissed the case. The Court rejected the appeals court’s interpretation of the Federal Tort Claims Act and the Supremacy Clause, clarifying that the Act’s exception for law enforcement actions should not be narrowly construed to shield the government from liability. While the Court did limit the scope of the “law enforcement proviso,” it ultimately paved the way for the family to pursue their claim for damages resulting from the FBI’s wrongful raid. This decision stems from a 2017 incident where the FBI mistakenly raided the Martin family home, causing significant distress and damages.
Read More
Federal immigration agents, executing a warrant for a human smuggling investigation, mistakenly raided the Oklahoma City home of a U.S. citizen family. The warrant listed previous residents as targets, not the current occupants, who were subjected to a nighttime search and seizure of their belongings, including phones, laptops, and cash. The mother reported the agents’ behavior as rough and dismissive despite her repeated assertions of citizenship. Homeland Security Investigations confirmed the raid, stating the incorrect address was included in the warrant, while the U.S. Marshals Service denied involvement.
Read More
Following a move from Maryland, Marisa and her family were subjected to a raid by agents identifying themselves as U.S. Marshals, ICE, and FBI. Despite repeatedly stating their U.S. citizenship, the family was forcibly removed from their home in their underwear, their house ransacked, and belongings seized. Marisa was left destitute, lacking funds for basic necessities like food and transportation, highlighting the devastating impact of the raid. The agents disregarded her pleas for assistance and the family’s clear citizenship.
Read More
In October 2017, FBI agents mistakenly raided Trina Martin’s home, causing significant trauma to her, her boyfriend, and her son. Martin subsequently filed a lawsuit against the government, but a federal judge and appeals court dismissed it, arguing courts shouldn’t second-guess police “honest mistakes.” The Supreme Court will now decide whether the Federal Tort Claims Act allows such lawsuits against the government for wrong-house raids, a question with conflicting precedent across different circuit courts. The case highlights the need for clarity on holding law enforcement accountable for such errors.
Read More
I can’t even begin to fathom the absurdity of a SWAT team raiding an innocent family’s home over a pair of stolen AirPods, only to find them nonchalantly lying on the street outside. The sheer incompetence and lack of judgment displayed in this situation is mind-boggling. It makes me question the priorities and capabilities of law enforcement in our society.
The fact that the family was detained outside while their home was essentially ransacked by the SWAT team is beyond outrageous. They have a three-month-old baby in the house, for heaven’s sake! The utter disregard for the well-being and safety of innocent individuals is alarming.… Continue reading
John Q. Hosedrinker