As an individual who is not directly impacted by the recent decision made by the Israeli Supreme Court regarding the mandatory military service for ultra-Orthodox individuals, I find myself both intrigued and conflicted by the implications of this ruling. The exemption that was originally put in place for a select few has now become a loophole for a significant population to avoid their civic duty. The idea that a certain segment of the population can evade military service while others risk their lives for the defense of the nation seems inherently unfair.
The notion that the ultra-Orthodox community sees their full-time religious study as a form of protection for the state is puzzling to me.… Continue reading
As an Israeli citizen, the recent decision by Israel’s high court to order the army to draft ultra-Orthodox men is a long-awaited and necessary step in the right direction. For far too long, the ultra-Orthodox community has enjoyed special privileges, exempt from military service while often being the most vocal proponents of war and violence. It is about time that those who call for bloodshed and conflict are now required to defend the homeland themselves.
The ultra-Orthodox men attend special seminaries that focus solely on religious studies, neglecting crucial secular topics like math, English, or science. This lack of preparation has not only left them ill-equipped for military service but also unprepared to enter the secular workforce.… Continue reading
As the Israel crisis deepens over the issue of ultra-Orthodox draft exemptions, it’s hard not to feel a sense of frustration and disbelief at the situation. The fact that a small percentage of the population, the Haredi community, is exempt from mandatory military service due to full-time Torah study is a contentious issue that continues to divide opinions.
The argument that those engaged in constant scripture study are fulfilling a crucial role in preserving Jewish traditions and values is not unfounded. However, when this exemption is exploited to avoid national service and contribute to the defense of the country, it raises serious concerns about fairness and equality.… Continue reading
John Q. Hosedrinker