Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor emphasized the importance of civic involvement and education during a recent speech. She questioned the public’s understanding of fundamental American principles, including the distinction between a president and a monarch. Sotomayor expressed concern over a lack of knowledge regarding the functions of the branches of government, advocating for more comprehensive civic education to address this deficit. While the justice did not directly address President Trump, her remarks touched on themes relevant to ongoing debates about the balance of power within the executive branch.
Read More
In a strongly worded dissent to the Supreme Court’s decision, Justice Sonia Sotomayor criticized the authorization of racial profiling by immigration agents, deeming it unconstitutional. She highlighted documented instances of physical force used by ICE agents in Los Angeles, who targeted individuals based on their appearance, language, and perceived profession. Sotomayor condemned the ruling, arguing it would subject countless individuals to unjust treatment, and directly challenged Justice Kavanaugh’s characterization of the ICE raids. Furthermore, Sotomayor asserted that the decision wrongly placed the burden on citizens to prove their legal status, effectively creating a second-class citizenship, in violation of the Fourth Amendment.
Read More
In a recent dissent, Justice Sonia Sotomayor criticized the Trump administration’s handling of immigration matters, accusing the court of “rewarding lawlessness” by supporting the administration’s emergency appeal to deport migrants. The dissent, joined by the court’s other liberals, specifically addressed the administration’s attempts to deport migrants to countries like South Sudan with minimal notice, despite lower court injunctions. Sotomayor argued that the government’s behavior threatened the rule of law by openly flouting court orders and repeatedly seeking relief from the Supreme Court on the emergency docket. This is the tenth time the court has granted a request from Trump on the emergency docket.
Read More
Senator Bernie Sanders has publicly stated his opposition to calls for Justice Sonia Sotomayor to step down from the Supreme Court, despite recent speculation among some Democrats that doing so would allow President Biden to appoint a liberal replacement before the end of his term. Sanders believes that such a move is “not sensible” and has not elaborated further on his stance. This speculation arises from the upcoming transition of power, which will see a Republican president and a likely Republican-controlled Senate, potentially impacting the court’s ideological balance in the future. The debate echoes the situation surrounding Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg’s refusal to step down during President Obama’s term, which ultimately led to her conservative replacement after her death.
Read More
John Q. Hosedrinker