Judge Deborah Oakes Evans recused herself from the Robert Roberson case, delaying his impending execution for the murder of his two-year-old daughter. Roberson, convicted in 2003, maintains his innocence, claiming his daughter’s death resulted from a fall and medication side effects, not abuse. The case has drawn significant public attention and legal challenges, particularly concerning the diagnosis of “shaken baby syndrome.” With Judge Evans’ recusal, the district attorney will determine the next steps in the proceedings.
Read More
I was a juror for a murder trial once, and the experience left me feeling uneasy about how our justice system operates, especially in cases where the evidence is not crystal clear. The trial I was a part of involved a father accused of murdering his own child based on what was later revealed to be outdated and debunked medical science, specifically related to Shaken Baby Syndrome. The doctor who conducted the autopsy claimed it was a homicide due to certain injuries, but upon further investigation, it was evident that the father may have been wrongfully accused. The lack of concrete evidence, conflicting testimonies, and the emotional toll it took on everyone involved made me question the reliability of our legal system in such cases.… Continue reading
As a Texan and a believer in justice, the recent case surrounding the potential execution of a man for a ‘shaken baby’ death has left me feeling conflicted and deeply concerned. The facts of the case are complex and raise significant questions about the reliability of the evidence presented. The father, who has an 8th-grade education and autism, brought his daughter to medical professionals in the days leading up to her tragic death due to what was later diagnosed as pneumonia. Despite seeking medical care for his child, he found himself in a nightmare scenario where his daughter ultimately perished.
The crux of the matter lies in the allegations of ‘Shaken Baby Syndrome’, a highly controversial and debated diagnosis within the medical and legal communities.… Continue reading
I am utterly shocked and disturbed upon reading the tragic news of the babysitter pleading guilty to manslaughter for the 2019 death of a man she injured as a baby in 1984. The impact of her actions goes beyond words, as the ripple effect of her momentary lapse of temper resulted in lifelong suffering and ultimately, a devastating loss of life.
Reading about the various accounts of shaken baby survivors who struggle with profound disabilities and limitations due to the actions of those entrusted to care for them is heart-wrenching. The stories shared of children robbed of their abilities to walk, talk, and lead fulfilling lives due to the irreversible damage caused in their infancy serve as a stark reminder of the power and responsibility that comes with caring for vulnerable individuals.… Continue reading
John Q. Hosedrinker