REAL ID

US Citizen Arrested Third Time While Suing ICE

Despite being a U.S. citizen and the lead plaintiff in a lawsuit against the Department of Homeland Security, Leo Garcia Venegas was detained and handcuffed for a third time by ICE officers earlier this month. This incident, where Venegas claims officers apprehended him without asking for identification and refused to examine his REAL ID, reinforces the argument made by his legal team that federal officers are enforcing immigration laws unconstitutionally. The Institute for Justice, representing Venegas, contends that DHS policies permit immigration agents to conduct dragnet raids on private construction sites, detain individuals without reasonable suspicion, and disregard evidence of citizenship. While DHS denies detaining Venegas and refutes allegations of racial profiling, the repeated encounters highlight the ongoing legal challenge to the agency’s enforcement practices.

Read More

West Virginia Bill Exempts Residents From Real ID Requirements

West Virginia Delegates Anders and Kimble have introduced House Bill 5514, proposing that state residents be exempt from mandatory Real ID requirements. The bill asserts that the Real ID Act of 2005 imposes unnecessary costs and inconveniences on citizens, and potentially infringes upon the Tenth Amendment. If passed, the Division of Motor Vehicles would cease mandatory Real ID implementation and report any federal attempts to enforce it, though residents could still voluntarily obtain a Real ID. This measure comes as Real IDs become a federal requirement for domestic air travel and entry into federal facilities starting in May 2025.

Read More

US Citizen Detained, Real ID Dismissed as Fake: Allegations of Harassment and Racism

In Foley, Alabama, Leonardo Garcia Venegas, a US citizen, was arrested during a Trump administration-led immigration raid targeting undocumented workers. Despite presenting a Real ID, authorities deemed it fake, wrestled him to the ground, and handcuffed him. After verifying his citizenship with his social security number, he was released hours later. The Department of Homeland Security claims Garcia Venegas interfered with the arrest, while his family highlights the incident as an example of the increasingly aggressive immigration enforcement impacting even US citizens.

Read More

US Citizen Handcuffed, ID Deemed Fake in ICE Raid

U.S. citizen Leonardo Garcia Venegas was arrested during an Alabama immigration raid, despite presenting a REAL ID, which authorities dismissed as fraudulent. Video footage shows Garcia being forcefully detained, handcuffed, and held in a vehicle before his release upon providing his Social Security number. The Department of Homeland Security claims Garcia interfered with the arrest, a claim he denies, stating he was attempting to use his phone. This incident, along with the detention of his undocumented brother, highlights concerns about racial profiling and the chilling effect of such raids on the Hispanic community.

Read More