In October 2017, FBI agents mistakenly raided Trina Martin’s home, causing significant trauma to her, her boyfriend, and her son. Martin subsequently filed a lawsuit against the government, but a federal judge and appeals court dismissed it, arguing courts shouldn’t second-guess police “honest mistakes.” The Supreme Court will now decide whether the Federal Tort Claims Act allows such lawsuits against the government for wrong-house raids, a question with conflicting precedent across different circuit courts. The case highlights the need for clarity on holding law enforcement accountable for such errors.
Read More
Brayan Rayo-Garzon, a Colombian migrant awaiting deportation, was found dead at the Phelps County Jail in Missouri on April 8th. His death occurred while he was in ICE custody following a March arrest for credit card fraud, and after an immigration judge ordered his removal in June 2024. While ICE reported notifying relevant authorities and next of kin, the agency’s handling of detainee deaths has faced significant criticism, with an independent investigation finding that a vast majority of deaths in ICE custody over a five-year period were potentially preventable due to inadequate medical care and flawed oversight. Currently, there is no evidence suggesting mistreatment contributed to Rayo-Garzon’s death.
Read More
Chicago is on track to exhaust its $82 million annual budget for police misconduct settlements just four months into the year. This staggering figure highlights a deeply flawed system where taxpayers repeatedly shoulder the financial burden of police misconduct. The very existence of such a large annual budget dedicated solely to settlements speaks volumes about the prevalence of misconduct within the Chicago Police Department (CPD).
It’s baffling that police unions aren’t required to maintain malpractice insurance, similar to doctors and lawyers. The current system lacks accountability, incentivizing misconduct because the financial consequences are borne by the public, not the officers involved.… Continue reading
Following a Saturday night officer-involved shooting in Pocatello, Idaho, approximately 50 protestors gathered to demonstrate outside the Pocatello Police Department. Graphic video footage of the incident, showing a man being shot multiple times by police officers after an apparent altercation involving a weapon, circulated widely on social media. The man, possibly a teenager with special needs, was hospitalized; his condition remains unknown. The East Idaho Critical Incident Task Force is investigating, while the Pocatello Police Department has yet to release a statement.
Read More
In 2020, the arrest of Amaurie Johnson by La Mesa police officer Matthew Dages sparked protests and riots. Following an investigation, Dages was fired and subsequently decertified under a 2021 state law, preventing him from working as an officer in California. This law, intended to enhance police accountability, has resulted in the decertification of nearly 300 officers statewide for various misconduct, though a significant backlog of cases at the California Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training (POST) threatens timely justice. The backlog, stemming from understaffing, risks allowing some officers to evade accountability due to expiring statutes of limitations.
Read More
A grand jury’s recommendation to immediately abolish an Alabama police department is a stark indictment of the system, highlighting a situation where serious misconduct went unchecked for an extended period. The sheer audacity of a dispatcher casually removing evidence – drugs, specifically – from the evidence room, walking down the hall with it, and using it in his office without raising a single eyebrow speaks volumes about a deeply ingrained culture of disregard for rules and accountability.
This blatant disregard for procedure wasn’t just an isolated incident; it apparently took the dispatcher overdosing on the job, surrounded by illicit substances, before any action was taken.… Continue reading
The Independent Police Conduct Authority (IPCA) criticized police for not filing criminal charges against an officer who admitted to assaulting his children with a belt. The IPCA determined the officer’s actions constituted three counts of child assault, despite the police concluding their investigation due to insufficient admissible evidence, stemming from the officer and his wife’s refusal to allow their children to be interviewed. Police internally censured the officer for serious misconduct, a sanction the IPCA deemed grossly inadequate. The IPCA noted that the police inexplicably cited the lack of criminal proceedings as a mitigating factor in their decision.
Read More
The family of Sonya Massey, a Black woman killed by an Illinois police officer, will receive a $10 million settlement. This outcome, while providing some financial relief, highlights a deeply troubling pattern: taxpayers are, in effect, perpetually bailing out police departments for the wrongful actions of their officers. The sheer volume of similar cases underscores a systemic issue that demands far more comprehensive reform than simply writing checks.
It’s easy to focus on the financial aspect—$10 million is a significant sum—but for the Massey family, no amount of money can replace their loss. The settlement doesn’t erase the trauma of Sonya’s death, nor does it bring her back.… Continue reading
Former Richland Police officer Jeremy Rast, dismissed for using derogatory slurs against Hispanic males in a recorded incident, has been hired by the Pearl Police Department. Rast’s comments, which included telling the group to “go back to Mexico,” were deemed unacceptable and unprofessional by Richland’s Chief of Police. Despite this dismissal, Pearl PD welcomed Rast, expressing excitement about his addition to their team. The Pearl Police Department’s announcement of his hiring has sparked controversy.
Read More
Trump’s pardon of two Washington D.C. police officers convicted in the death of a Black man, Karon Hylton-Brown, has ignited a firestorm of controversy. The decision, announced seemingly without much fanfare, raises serious questions about justice, accountability, and the ongoing struggle for racial equality in America.
The pardon itself is a stark reminder of the power vested in the presidency, especially concerning the ability to overturn criminal convictions. This power, while constitutionally granted, has historically been wielded with caution, often reserved for cases of significant extenuating circumstances or demonstrable flaws in the legal process. In this instance, the lack of transparency surrounding the pardon and the apparent lack of such justification fuels widespread public outrage.… Continue reading
John Q. Hosedrinker 
Matt Underwood