A U.S. appeals court has lifted a block on a Louisiana law requiring public schools to display the Ten Commandments, voting 12-6 to allow the statute to proceed. The court’s majority opinion stated that it was too early to judge the law’s constitutionality, citing insufficient details on how the displays would be implemented and used in classrooms. While supporters hailed the decision as a victory for common sense and tradition, opponents vowed to continue legal challenges, asserting the law unconstitutionally promotes religion in schools. This ruling follows a trend of similar laws being enacted and contested across the nation, with the debate centering on the separation of church and state versus the historical significance of the Ten Commandments.
Read More
A Louisiana federal courtroom is set to hear arguments regarding the constitutionality of a law mandating the display of the Ten Commandments in public schools. This case will be heard by all 17 active judges of the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, an unusual occurrence. The legal challenge stems from concerns about the First Amendment’s establishment clause and the potential endorsement of a specific religion. Both Texas and Louisiana have laws mandating the display of the Ten Commandments, prompting lawsuits and differing rulings from lower courts, with appeals expected regardless of the outcome.
Read More
Texas schools are navigating a new state law mandating the display of the Ten Commandments in classrooms, leading to varied reactions. Some teachers, like Gigi Cervantes, have resigned in protest, while others, such as Dustin Parsons, view the displays as historical context. Despite legal challenges, including court orders against the mandate, many schools are implementing the law and receiving donated posters. The issue has sparked debate among students, parents, and school staff, raising questions about religious freedom and the role of schools.
Read More
A judge issued a temporary injunction against Texas’s new law mandating the display of the Ten Commandments in public school classrooms. This ruling, the third against such a state law, was in response to a lawsuit filed by Dallas-area families and faith leaders who argued the requirement violated the First Amendment. The ruling is expected to escalate the legal battle, potentially reaching the U.S. Supreme Court, as similar laws in Louisiana and Arkansas have faced legal challenges. The court reasoned that the law would force teachers to answer questions about the Ten Commandments, effectively promoting religion in the classroom.
Read More
A federal judge has blocked Arkansas public schools from displaying the Ten Commandments, calling the law “obviously unconstitutional” and citing potential violations of the First Amendment. The judge issued a preliminary injunction against the Arkansas law, which would have mandated displays in classrooms and libraries. This decision was made in response to similar laws passed in other states, like Louisiana and Texas, and legal challenges are underway against those measures. The judge argued the state’s actions may be part of a broader strategy to introduce Christian religious doctrine into public schools, especially in light of recent Supreme Court rulings.
Read More
A federal appeals court declared Louisiana’s law mandating Ten Commandments displays in public schools unconstitutional, siding with plaintiffs who argued it violated the separation of church and state. This ruling, upholding a lower court’s decision, stems from a lawsuit filed by parents of children from diverse religious backgrounds. While the state attorney general plans to appeal, arguing the ruling’s limited scope, the appeals court’s decision binds all Louisiana school districts. The case is expected to reach the Supreme Court, potentially revisiting prior Supreme Court precedent on similar religious displays in public spaces.
Read More
The Texas Senate passed SB 10, mandating Ten Commandments displays in all public schools, by a 20-11 party-line vote. Supporters argued the Commandments are foundational to American law and ethics, while opponents cited potential First Amendment violations, specifically the Establishment Clause. The bill now proceeds to the House; if enacted, legal challenges are anticipated given a similar law’s temporary blockage in Louisiana. Debate included discussion of religious freedom and the Supreme Court’s evolving stance on such displays.
Read More
Senate Bill 114, proposing mandatory Ten Commandments displays in Montana public schools, was defeated for a second time. Despite amendments allowing, rather than requiring, district funding, the bill failed to garner enough support, with eight Republicans joining Democrats in opposition. Opponents argued the bill was unconstitutional, citing the First Amendment and lack of tribal consultation, while proponents emphasized the historical significance of the Commandments to American law and heritage. The Senate ultimately voted to indefinitely postpone the measure, effectively killing it for the session.
Read More
A bill mandating the display and teaching of the Ten Commandments in South Dakota public schools failed to pass the state House. Opponents argued the bill was unconstitutional, citing potential legal challenges and noting out-of-state support from organizations like WallBuilders. While supporters claimed the Commandments are foundational to American law and culture, the bill’s defeat followed a debate highlighting concerns over government endorsement of religion. Even an amendment reducing the number of required displays did not garner enough support.
Read More
A federal judge in Louisiana has blocked a new state law requiring public schools to display the Ten Commandments, ruling it unconstitutional. The judge determined the law’s primary purpose was religious, citing its lack of historical significance compared to other foundational documents. He also argued that the law amounts to government coercion of students, as parents are required to send their children to school. The judge’s ruling granted a preliminary injunction, suggesting the law is likely to be permanently struck down. This decision comes as part of a broader trend of conservative efforts to incorporate religion into public schools, reflecting a national debate about the separation of church and state.
Read More
John Q. Hosedrinker