The Supreme Court’s 5-4 decision weakens the Clean Water Act by restricting the EPA’s ability to set generic pollution limits for permit holders. The ruling, authored by Justice Alito, sided with San Francisco’s challenge to EPA permits that held permittees responsible for overall water quality. The majority opinion argued the EPA possesses sufficient tools to obtain necessary information without resorting to “end-result” requirements. Dissenting justices argued this decision contradicts the Clean Water Act’s mandate for stringent limitations to meet water quality standards. The ruling represents a significant shift in environmental regulation.
Read More
A Florida appellate court upheld a state law preventing local governments from granting rights to natural resources, thereby rejecting a Titusville clean water initiative passed by 83% of voters. The court’s decision, mirroring a similar ruling in Orange County, cites a 2020 state law preempting such local ordinances. While acknowledging the initiative’s popular support and laudable goals, the judges ruled they lacked authority to overturn the state legislature’s mandate. This ruling effectively blocks citizen lawsuits to protect Titusville’s waterways.
Read More
An analysis by Food & Water Watch reveals Iowa’s Department of Natural Resources inadequately penalizes factory farms for illegally discharging manure into waterways, resulting in over one million fish deaths from 179 recorded incidents between 2013 and 2023. These spills, totaling up to one million gallons, carry harmful contaminants linked to serious health issues, yet violators paid less than $750,000 in fines. The report highlights a state-wide problem, with a concentration in northwest Iowa, and connects this pollution to elevated cancer rates. This insufficient enforcement, coupled with a lack of monitoring at many large farms, contributes to millions of dollars in taxpayer-funded water cleanup costs annually.
Read More
John Q. Hosedrinker