The Trump administration’s assertion that it bears no responsibility for returning an illegally deported Maryland man to the United States is deeply troubling. Their claim hinges on a narrow interpretation of a Supreme Court ruling, arguing that the court’s mandate to “facilitate” the man’s return only requires adjusting his immigration status upon his release from a high-security El Salvadoran prison. This interpretation effectively shifts the onus entirely onto El Salvador, absolving the administration of any proactive role in securing his repatriation.
This position raises serious concerns about the administration’s commitment to upholding the rule of law. The Supreme Court’s unanimous decision clearly implied a more active role from the U.S.… Continue reading
Following a Supreme Court order to “facilitate” the return of Kilmar Abrego Garcia, illegally deported to El Salvador, the Trump administration argues it has no obligation to bring him back to the U.S. The Justice Department claims “facilitate” refers only to removing domestic obstacles to his return, not actively securing his release from El Salvador’s notorious CECOT prison. Simultaneously, the administration refuses to release details of its agreement with El Salvador to hold deported migrants, citing various privileges. Despite the Supreme Court deeming Abrego Garcia’s deportation illegal, the Department of Homeland Security contends his protection from removal is invalid due to alleged MS-13 gang membership.
Read More
A judge has ordered daily updates on whether the Trump administration is complying with a court order to return an illegally deported man to the United States. This unprecedented demand underscores the gravity of the situation and the apparent lack of cooperation from the administration. The judge’s action is a clear attempt to hold the administration accountable and ensure transparency in a case with potentially life-or-death consequences.
The daily updates requirement, however, is being met with resistance. The Justice Department has indicated a potential delay in complying until at least Monday, citing unpreparedness. This delay raises concerns that the administration is deliberately dragging its feet, possibly allowing more time for irreversible harm to befall the deported individual.… Continue reading
A federal judge ordered the Trump administration to return Kilmar Abrego Garcia, a protected Maryland resident mistakenly deported to a dangerous El Salvadoran prison, to the United States. The Department of Justice appealed, arguing a lack of authority to compel El Salvador’s cooperation, but the judge rejected this claim, stating the U.S. cannot outsource its prison system and then claim inability to act. The judge deemed the deportation an illegal act resulting from the administration’s use of an 18th-century law for mass deportations without due process. Garcia’s deportation was described as an “administrative error,” yet the government’s refusal to disclose his current status and the dangers he faces fueled the judge’s decision.
Read More
Judge Paula Xinis has ordered the Trump administration to return Kilmar Abrego Garcia to the U.S. after he was erroneously deported to El Salvador’s dangerous CECOT prison. The deportation stemmed from an admitted administrative error, despite Abrego Garcia having previously been granted protection from deportation due to gang threats in El Salvador. The judge rejected the administration’s claims that Abrego Garcia is an MS-13 gang member, citing a lack of evidence and highlighting the government’s own ability to transport detainees from CECOT. Xinis emphasized the illegality of Abrego Garcia’s arrest, detention, and deportation, deeming his situation “wholly lawless.”
Read More
A federal judge ordered the immediate return of Kilmar Abrego Garcia to the US after his wrongful deportation to El Salvador, where he was imprisoned. The judge deemed the deportation an illegal act, as the Justice Department offered no explanation for his removal despite possessing no legal authority to arrest him. Abrego Garcia, who had legal work authorization and protection from deportation, was wrongly accused of gang affiliation based on unsubstantiated claims. His wife, a US citizen, and their children await his return.
Read More
Matt Underwood 
John Q. Hosedrinker