Fifth Amendment

FBI Director Grilled on Fifth Amendment Interpretation

Senator Shanahan expressed shock and betrayal over the HHS appointments of Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s siblings, contrary to prior assurances. This follows Kennedy’s recent decision-making seemingly influenced by an unknown third party, not President Trump. The situation is further complicated by Kennedy’s history of promoting controversial and unfounded claims, aligning with the anti-vaccine stances of his appointed siblings. Shanahan’s statement highlights a significant internal conflict within the Kennedy campaign.

Read More

Trump Admits Uncertainty About Upholding the Constitution

During a recent interview, President Trump responded “I don’t know” when asked if he has an obligation to uphold the Constitution, specifically regarding due process for immigrants. This followed his administration’s deportation of individuals, including those with prior legal protection, actions that have been challenged in court. Trump claimed a mandate to deport immigrants despite judicial rulings against his methods, citing the Supreme Court’s interpretation of the issue as differing from his own. He also disregarded the Fifth Amendment’s guarantee of due process for all persons within the U.S., citing the logistical challenges of individual trials.

Read More

Trump Admits Uncertainty About Upholding Constitution

President Trump’s prioritization of mass deportations has led to clashes with the judiciary over due process rights for immigrants. He expressed uncertainty about the Fifth Amendment’s applicability, suggesting the required legal processes would be excessively time-consuming. The administration’s actions, including the controversial use of the Alien Enemies Act and the deportation of Kilmar Abrego Garcia, have faced Supreme Court rebuke, highlighting a pattern of circumventing established legal procedures. Despite claiming adherence to legal counsel, Trump’s approach has consistently challenged judicial rulings and constitutional protections for immigrants.

Read More

House Republicans Defy Law, Attempt to Authorize ICE Deportation of US Citizens

Despite Democratic efforts to prevent deportations without due process, amendments to a budget bill aimed at barring ICE from such actions, including the deportation of U.S. citizens, failed to pass the House Judiciary Committee. These amendments followed President Trump’s suggestion of sending U.S. citizens to a Salvadoran prison and actual deportations of Venezuelan citizens to that facility without legal proceedings. Democrats criticized Republicans for implicitly supporting the circumvention of Fifth Amendment rights. The rejection of these amendments leaves ICE with the ability to proceed with deportations under the current legal framework.

Read More

RFK Jr.’s Bird Flu Plan: Let It Spread to Find Immune Birds?

A federal judge rejected the Trump administration’s attempt to dismiss the case of Mahmoud Khalil, a Columbia University graduate student facing deportation, transferring it to New Jersey. The judge found the case outside his jurisdiction but upheld an order preventing Khalil’s removal from the country pending the New Jersey court’s decision. Khalil, a legal U.S. resident, alleges his arrest and attempted deportation violated his First and Fifth Amendment rights due to his participation in pro-Palestine protests. The government’s accusations of Khalil’s ties to terrorism remain unsubstantiated.

Read More

Trump’s Deportations: First and Fifth Amendment Violations Alleged

A lawsuit filed by a Cornell professor and two students, with the support of the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee (ADC), alleges that the Trump administration unconstitutionally suppressed free speech through executive orders. The plaintiffs claim these orders, enforced via deportation and other means, target individuals expressing pro-Palestinian views, citing the detainment of a Columbia University student as an example. This chilling effect has led plaintiffs to self-censor and limit public engagement for fear of government retaliation. The ADC seeks a temporary restraining order to block enforcement of the relevant executive orders, arguing they violate the First and Fifth Amendments.

Read More

Pentagon Memo Orders Purge of Transgender Troops

The Trump administration issued a memo mandating the separation of transgender service members from the military, citing incompatibility with service requirements and national security interests. This action, following a January executive order targeting transgender troops, demands the Pentagon identify and begin separating these individuals within 60 days, with waivers granted only in exceptional circumstances directly supporting warfighting capabilities. The memo represents a significant escalation of previous restrictions on transgender service, prompting legal challenges arguing the policy violates the Fifth Amendment’s equal protection clause. The department’s stated goal is to enforce high standards of readiness, lethality, and integrity within the military.

Read More

Trans Inmate Sues Trump Over Prison Assignment and Healthcare Denial

A transgender woman, identified as Maria Moe, is suing Donald Trump over a recent executive order mandating the placement of transgender women in men’s prisons. This federal lawsuit, the first of its kind, alleges the order violates Moe’s Fifth and Eighth Amendment rights by exposing her to extreme risks of violence and denying her gender-affirming care. The order dictates that only two biological sexes are recognized, impacting incarcerated transgender individuals disproportionately. Moe’s transfer to a men’s facility would severely endanger her safety and well-being.

Read More