Judge Upholds Race in Naval Academy Admissions: Diversity Trumps Meritocracy Debate
Judge Richard Bennett ruled that the U.S. Naval Academy may continue considering race in admissions, citing a compelling national security interest in a diverse officer corps. The judge found that the academy’s use of race is narrowly tailored to achieve this interest, rejecting arguments from Students for Fair Admissions that the Supreme Court’s affirmative action ruling should apply. While race is a minor factor, the court recognized the military’s need for a representative and cohesive force, emphasizing the importance of diversity for mission effectiveness. Students for Fair Admissions plans to appeal the decision.
John Q. Hosedrinker