Council on Criminal Justice

NYPD Officer Sentenced For Fatal Cooler Throw

A former New York City police sergeant has been sentenced to three to nine years in prison for manslaughter in the death of Eric Duprey. The sergeant tossed a cooler at Duprey, who was fleeing on a motorized scooter, causing him to crash and die. This marks the first time in at least two decades an NYPD officer has been imprisoned for an on-duty death. The judge rejected the sergeant’s defense that his actions were justified, concluding he was upset the suspect was escaping.

Read More

Alabama Commutes Death Sentence for Man Who Didn’t Kill Victim

Governor Kay Ivey commuted Charles “Sonny” Burton’s death sentence to life without parole, deeming his execution unjust due to the disparate punishment compared to the man who committed the murder. Burton was involved in a 1991 robbery that resulted in a customer’s death, but he did not fire the fatal shot and had left the scene before the killing occurred. The governor cited the legal doctrine of felony murder, which held Burton accountable for the homicide, but contrasted this with the life sentence received by the actual triggerman. This decision followed appeals for clemency, including a plea from the victim’s daughter, and avoided Burton becoming the second individual executed under Alabama’s new nitrogen gas method.

Read More

Alexander Brothers Convicted of All Sex Trafficking Charges

The Alexander brothers have been found guilty of all charges in their sex-trafficking trial, a verdict that brings a close to a case filled with disturbing allegations and courtroom drama. This outcome signifies a significant moment, suggesting that even those with privilege and influence are not entirely beyond the reach of justice.

The trial’s progression was not without its complexities, as prosecutors ultimately dropped two counts due to intimidation tactics employed by the defense. It was revealed that a private investigator, hired by the defense team, allegedly impersonated an insurance agent to gather information about a crucial accuser, even inquiring about her children and visiting her neighborhood.… Continue reading

Trump Pardoned Jan 6 Rioter Now Convicted of Child Molestation

A Jan. 6 rioter, Andrew Paul Johnson, who received a presidential pardon from Donald Trump, has been convicted of serious child sex offenses in Florida. Johnson was found guilty by a jury on five charges, including molesting minors and transmitting harmful materials electronically. Prosecutors stated Johnson attempted to use an anticipated financial payout from the Trump administration as a way to silence one of his victims. Johnson faces a potential life sentence when he is sentenced in March.

Read More

Attempted Trump Assassin Sentenced to Life in Prison Amid Controversy

The recent sentencing of an individual who attempted to assassinate Donald Trump has sent ripples through the nation, bringing to the forefront complex questions about justice, mental health, and the impartiality of the legal system. The accused, identified as Routh, was found guilty and handed a life sentence plus an additional seven years, a penalty that has sparked considerable debate, especially given the highly charged political landscape surrounding the former president. The narrative begins with Routh allegedly hiding in the bushes near the Trump International Golf Club in West Palm Beach, a military-grade SKS rifle pointed directly at Trump and a Secret Service agent.… Continue reading

Minneapolis Shooting: Agents on Leave Sparks Outrage, Calls for Justice

US agents involved in the latest Minneapolis shooting are reportedly on leave, a situation that immediately sparks a wave of reactions, ranging from outrage to calls for justice. The news itself, that agents involved in a shooting are placed on leave, sets the stage for a discussion about accountability and the handling of such incidents. The fact that the agents are on paid leave, as the reports indicate, likely fuels much of the immediate anger. The natural reaction is: Is this a punishment or a reward?

Speaking of punishment, the Canadian experience with border services provides a stark contrast. The Canadian Border Services Agency, or CBSA, rarely fires their service pistols.… Continue reading

US Homicide Rates Plunge: Significant Drops in Many Cities

According to a new report from the Council on Criminal Justice, data from 35 American cities reveals a 21% decrease in the homicide rate from 2024 to 2025, resulting in approximately 922 fewer homicides. The report, released on Thursday, also tracked 13 crimes and found declines in 11 categories, including carjackings and shoplifting, while drug crimes saw a small increase and sexual assaults remained stable. Experts suggest that the drop in homicides and other crimes extends beyond the surveyed cities, though the underlying causes remain unclear, with both Democrats and Republicans claiming credit for the trend.

Read More