Constitutional Interpretation

Roberts Says Public Is Wrong To See Justices As Political

Chief Justice John Roberts recently addressed public perceptions of the Supreme Court, asserting that the institution is often misunderstood as a political body making policy-based decisions rather than interpreting the law. He emphasized that the Court is obligated to issue rulings that may not be popular, driven by their interpretation of the Constitution and its application. Roberts expressed concern over the public’s perceived lack of understanding regarding the Court’s operational framework and reiterated the importance of focusing criticism on the substance of decisions, not individual justices, especially in light of rising security concerns.

Read More

Hawaii Supreme Court quotes “The Wire” in ruling on gun rights: “The thing about the old days, they the old days”

The Hawaii Supreme Court recently made headlines for quoting a line from the TV series “The Wire” in a ruling on gun rights. The quote, “The thing about the old days, they the old days,” was used to emphasize that the culture and norms of the past should not dictate contemporary life. While some have criticized this approach, I believe that it raises important questions about the interpretation of the Constitution and the relevance of historical context.

One of the main questions that arises from this ruling is whether the argument can be applied to other amendments in the Bill of Rights or if it is limited to the Second Amendment.… Continue reading