Botched Execution

Tennessee Fails Execution: Botched IV Leads to Year Delay

Tennessee officials halted the lethal injection of Tony Carruthers, convicted of kidnapping and murdering three people in 1994, after executioners were unable to establish an intravenous line for over an hour. The state’s protocol requires a backup IV line, and attempts to insert a central line also failed, leading to the postponement of the execution. This incident, where witnesses reported Carruthers wincing and groaning during the process, mirrors similar difficulties in other states and raises questions about the qualifications of execution personnel and the efficacy of lethal injection. Carruthers’ case also involves arguments about his mental competency and claims of innocence, with the ACLU pushing for DNA testing on existing evidence.

Read More

South Carolina Firing Squad Execution Botched: Lawyers Claim Bullets Mostly Missed Inmate’s Heart

A pathologist’s report commissioned by Mikal Mahdi’s attorneys claims his April 11th firing squad execution was botched. Only two bullet wounds were found, suggesting the shooters missed the intended target area, resulting in a prolonged and painful death estimated at 30-60 seconds. The autopsy lacked crucial evidence, including X-rays and detailed photos, hindering independent verification of the state’s claim that three bullets struck Mahdi. Attorneys argue this contradicts the state’s assurance of a humane execution and calls into question the training and oversight of the process.

Read More