A Vermont federal judge ordered the release of Mohsen Mahdawi, a Palestinian green-card holder and Columbia University student, who had been detained by the Trump administration for deportation despite facing no criminal charges. The judge ruled that the government failed to justify Mahdawi’s continued detention, citing a lack of evidence suggesting he was a flight risk or danger, and noting that his detention could chill protected speech. Mahdawi’s release is pending the resolution of his case, allowing him to continue his studies and legal representation. This decision follows legal challenges by other Palestinian activists facing similar deportation orders based on an obscure foreign policy statute. The case highlights concerns about the potential for retaliatory actions against those advocating for Palestinian human rights.
Read More
The White House is exploring all legal options to expedite deportations, including potentially suspending the writ of habeas corpus for migrants, a measure previously employed by past presidents during national crises. This follows criticism of the administration’s deportation rate, which, while significantly reducing border crossings, has not yet met the ambitious goals set by some conservatives. Press Secretary Leavitt affirmed the administration’s commitment to exploring all legal and constitutional avenues to achieve its deportation objectives. The administration points to a dramatic decrease in border crossings as evidence of its success.
Read More
Abrego Garcia’s family’s lawsuit prompted urgent discussions within the Departments of State, Justice, and Homeland Security regarding his deportation. Initial plans for his return were considered, but White House backlash led to a reversal, recasting his deportation as justified due to his alleged, yet unproven, MS-13 affiliation. This narrative shift transformed the case into a larger test of the administration’s power to deport individuals without due process. The lack of evidence supporting Trump’s claims became a central point of contention.
Read More
Following a 2021 federal judge’s dismissal of his case due to unreliable evidence, Ameen was immediately rearrested by ICE and subsequently deported to Rwanda under the Biden administration. This deportation, based on weak evidence, marks Ameen as the first Trump-era deportation to Rwanda. His previous statement expressing gratitude for the justice system and his love for America stands in stark contrast to his current situation. The question of restitution and potential long-term displacement remains unanswered.
Read More
Following a scathing rebuke for insufficient responses, a federal judge granted the Department of Justice a one-week extension to answer questions regarding the deportation of Kilmar Abrego Garcia. The judge deemed the administration’s previous responses willful noncompliance and an attempt to obstruct discovery, rejecting claims that Abrego Garcia, deported despite court protections, is an MS-13 gang member. The Justice Department, citing various legal privileges, continues to resist facilitating Abrego Garcia’s return as ordered by the Supreme Court, despite the lack of substantiating evidence. This defiance, mirroring similar cases involving Venezuelan migrants, threatens a major constitutional conflict between the judiciary and executive branches.
Read More
A Maryland federal judge ordered the Trump administration to return a 20-year-old Venezuelan man wrongly deported to El Salvador, citing a breach of a 2024 settlement agreement protecting unaccompanied minors. This marks the second such order concerning deportations to El Salvador, following a similar case involving Kilmar Abrego Garcia. The administration argued the deportation was justified under the Alien Enemies Act, but the judge disagreed, deeming the matter a contractual dispute. The ruling also protects another Venezuelan man, Javier, from imminent deportation under the same agreement.
Read More
Brayan Rayo-Garzon, a Colombian migrant awaiting deportation, was found dead at the Phelps County Jail in Missouri on April 8th. His death occurred while he was in ICE custody following a March arrest for credit card fraud, and after an immigration judge ordered his removal in June 2024. While ICE reported notifying relevant authorities and next of kin, the agency’s handling of detainee deaths has faced significant criticism, with an independent investigation finding that a vast majority of deaths in ICE custody over a five-year period were potentially preventable due to inadequate medical care and flawed oversight. Currently, there is no evidence suggesting mistreatment contributed to Rayo-Garzon’s death.
Read More
Following the unlawful deportation of Abrego Garcia to El Salvador, the Supreme Court mandated his repatriation, an order echoed by U.S. District Judge Paula Xinis. Despite these rulings, the Department of Justice (DOJ) has failed to act, citing unsubstantiated claims of gang affiliation based on his tattoos. The DOJ’s response to subsequent inquiries was dismissive, refusing to answer questions and incorrectly identifying El Salvador while dismissing the court orders as a “false premise.” This inaction directly contradicts the Supreme Court’s directive to “facilitate” Abrego Garcia’s return to the United States.
Read More
John Q. Hosedrinker