By John Q. Hosedrinker 
A Sherpa guide, Dawa Sherpa, was miraculously found crawling to base camp on Mount Everest a week after he went missing. His family had already begun funeral rituals, having given up hope for his return. Dawa was located by a cleaning crew near the Khumbu Icefall and subsequently airlifted to a hospital in Kathmandu. His survival after being last seen descending the mountain at a significant altitude is being hailed as extraordinary within the mountaineering community.
Read the original article here
In a remarkable display of resilience, 52-year-old Sherpa guide Dawa Sherpa was miraculously found alive on Mount Everest after a harrowing week-long ordeal without food, water, or supplemental oxygen. Dawa, last seen on May 29th, was guiding a client near the “Yellow Band,” a section of the mountain situated above Camp 3 at an altitude of 7,200 meters. As the climbing season drew to a close and essential safety infrastructure was being dismantled, a cleaning crew from the Sagarmatha Pollution Control Committee stumbled upon him on June 4th. He was discovered crawling down the snow-laden slopes, not far from the treacherous Khumbu Icefall, and remarkably close to Everest Base Camp.
Upon his discovery, Dawa was swiftly brought to safety, provided with much-needed sustenance and hydration, and then airlifted by rescue helicopter to HAMS Hospital in Kathmandu. His improbable return brought immense relief to his family, who had, by all accounts, begun the somber process of funeral rituals, having already accepted his presumed death. Dawa is presently undergoing intensive care for severe dehydration, trauma, and frostbite. While the Nepalese mountaineering community has rightly lauded his survival as nothing short of miraculous, the incident has also sparked a debate regarding a perceived delay in initiating search and rescue efforts. The sheer tenacity of his survival, even after being trapped in a crevasse for two and a half days before snow conditions allowed him to crawl out, has led many to describe him as an absolute legend, embodying an almost superhuman level of toughness.
The notion of surviving for a week in such an unforgiving wilderness, especially on the formidable slopes of Mount Everest, is truly astounding. It underscores the extraordinary resilience and physical prowess of these guides, who are often viewed as being beyond ordinary human capabilities. To emerge from such an ordeal after a full week missing, and without sustaining life-altering injuries, is nothing short of incredible and speaks volumes about his fortitude. The narrative of his survival has been likened to dramatic survival stories, evoking the tension and sheer will to live seen in documentaries and survival shows. The fact that his last name is Sherpa, a name synonymous with mountaineering expertise and endurance on Everest, seems almost fated, as if he were destined to “sherpa” his way out of such a dire situation.
However, alongside the awe and admiration for Dawa’s survival, concerns have been raised regarding the actions of the guiding company that employed him. Reports suggest a potential abandonment, with the company allegedly packing up and leaving without a robust initial search effort to locate him. This raises difficult questions about the responsibility owed to guides and the protocols in place for their safety. The age of 52, and still undertaking such demanding climbs, is remarkable, highlighting an almost inhuman level of dedication and physical capability. The timeline for a family to presume someone dead after a week is also a point of discussion, especially given the unpredictable nature of high-altitude expeditions, though for those awaiting news from Everest, a week can feel like an eternity.
The situation has drawn parallels to the harrowing experience depicted in “Touching the Void,” a testament to the extreme circumstances faced on the mountain. While some might view these individuals as merely tough, others suggest a more profound biological adaptation, perhaps making them a unique form of “augmentary extremophile.” Despite his incredible survival, the reality of his condition is serious, with significant frostbite and dehydration necessitating a prolonged intensive care stay. While he fought valiantly for his life, it’s crucial to acknowledge the severity of his injuries, even as we celebrate his triumphant return.
The alleged abandonment by the guiding company and the client he was with has drawn sharp criticism, with many condemning such actions as irresponsible and unacceptable. The overwhelming consensus is that the guiding company, in particular, has a significant duty of care that appears to have been neglected. While the mountain is undeniably littered with the remains of those who did not survive, and even corpses are used as grim landmarks, the question remains whether sufficient effort was made to rescue Dawa. It’s important to distinguish between the inherent risks of Everest, where rescue attempts can themselves be fatal, and the potential dereliction of duty by those responsible for his safety. The decision to leave a climber behind, especially when they are in distress, is a complex and often ethically fraught one, but the subsequent lack of a concerted rescue effort raises serious ethical considerations.
The circumstances surrounding Dawa’s disappearance and the subsequent search have also brought to light the challenging dynamics of high-altitude rescue. It’s understood that falling into a crevasse can be a near-certain death sentence, and the decision to proceed rather than attempt a recovery in such conditions is often made with survival of the remaining team in mind. However, the timeline of events and the perceived lack of urgency in organizing a search are critical points of contention. The fact that Dawa survived for so long, and eventually crawled back to safety, fuels the argument that he deserved a more immediate and comprehensive search, especially given his expertise and resilience.
Furthermore, the late timing of the expedition itself, pushing the boundaries of the climbing season, and the unusually late summit time, have been identified as potentially contributing factors to the perilous situation. These decisions, made by the entire team, underscore the high-stakes nature of Everest expeditions and the critical importance of timing and risk assessment. Dawa’s ability to descend the mountain after such an ordeal, despite his weakened state, is a testament to his extraordinary will to survive and his intimate knowledge of the terrain. It’s a powerful reminder that even in the face of overwhelming odds, the human spirit can achieve the seemingly impossible.
The debate over whether the guiding company and the client made the right decisions in leaving Dawa behind is a complex one, involving survival ethics and the harsh realities of Everest. While some argue that prioritizing self-preservation is paramount to avoid becoming another victim, others contend that a greater effort should have been made to ensure his rescue, especially given his status as an experienced guide. The criticism leveled at the company for the delay in organizing a search, and the wife’s dissatisfaction with their response, highlights a systemic issue that requires careful examination and potential reform. The narrative that Dawa was not in a crevasse when he was left, but rather fell into one later while trying to descend alone, adds another layer of complexity to the understanding of the events.
Ultimately, Dawa Sherpa’s survival is a beacon of hope and a testament to human endurance. Yet, his story also serves as a crucial reminder of the responsibilities and ethical obligations inherent in high-altitude guiding and mountaineering. It calls for a critical re-evaluation of safety protocols, search and rescue procedures, and the duty of care owed to all individuals undertaking these perilous expeditions, ensuring that such extraordinary acts of survival are not overshadowed by preventable tragedies or questions of accountability. The incident necessitates a broader conversation about what constitutes adequate preparation, responsible decision-making, and ultimately, how we can better protect those who guide us through the world’s most dangerous terrains.