By John Q. Hosedrinker 
Astronaut Mike Fincke, who experienced the first medical evacuation from the International Space Station this year, stated that the cause of his sudden illness remains unknown. The episode, which occurred during dinner on January 7, rendered him unable to speak and caused distress to his crewmates, prompting a medical emergency response. While doctors have ruled out a heart attack and choking, the exact reason for the incident, which lasted about 20 minutes, is still under investigation, with potential links to his extensive time in weightlessness. NASA is examining other astronauts’ medical records for similar occurrences as they continue to investigate the event.
Read the original article here
The notion of a NASA astronaut suddenly being unable to speak in the silent expanse of space is, quite frankly, the stuff of movie trailers. It conjures images of isolation and an unnerving inability to cry out for help. Fortunately, this astronaut is back on Earth, and the incident, though startling, ultimately remains a medical enigma.
The astronaut in question, a seasoned space traveler, experienced a roughly 20-minute episode where his ability to speak vanished. What’s particularly perplexing is that he felt perfectly fine both during and after this alarming event. This sudden loss of speech, especially when accompanied by a feeling of overall well-being, prompts a cascade of questions and theories.
Many have speculated about the cause, with mild strokes or transient ischemic attacks (TIAs) frequently mentioned as possibilities. These events, though often temporary, can manifest in speech difficulties. The fact that he feels completely normal afterward does add a layer of complexity to this particular case, as it doesn’t immediately align with the typical presentation of such conditions.
Another strong contender for explanation revolves around migraine auras. It’s been noted that some pre-migraine symptoms can closely resemble stroke symptoms, including aphasia, which is the impairment of language. For those who have experienced aphasia due to a migraine, it’s described as profoundly terrifying, especially the sudden and unexpected nature of it, and the fact that it can resolve completely, leaving one feeling otherwise healthy.
The unique environment of space itself has also been brought up as a potential contributing factor. Living in orbit for extended periods, far removed from the familiar pull of gravity and the comforts of solid ground, could conceivably trigger unusual physiological responses. The idea that “we all do better with two feet on the ground” resonates when considering the body’s adaptation to such an alien setting.
The possibility of a focal seizure, leading to postictal aphasia (difficulty speaking after a seizure), has also been considered, though it’s assumed that NASA’s medical professionals would have thoroughly investigated such serious conditions. The mention of brain tumors, while understandably concerning, is also acknowledged as something that experienced medical teams would likely rule out early on.
More out-there theories, fueled by the dramatic nature of the incident, include the more imaginative explanations. While humorous, the idea of “space aliens with an invisible laser” or “eldritch beings stealing voices” highlights the profound sense of the unknown that space exploration can evoke. Even a more grounded, yet still fantastical, explanation involves high-energy solar particles potentially affecting the brain’s speech centers.
Another perspective points to functional neurological disorders (FND), where stress can lead to a loss of speech. While FND often presents with other symptoms, the core mechanism of stress impacting communication is noted as a parallel. This aligns with the experience of people who have had temporary speech loss following head injuries, like concussions, where clear thoughts become jumbled words.
The timeline of the astronaut’s space missions has also raised some confusion, with different mission durations mentioned. This detail, while seemingly minor, can sometimes add to the overall puzzle when trying to piece together what might have contributed to the episode.
The camaraderie and concern shown by his crewmates offer a touching insight into the incident. Their reassurances, such as “This wasn’t you. This was space, right?”, suggest that they, too, were contemplating the unique influence of their environment. The mention of having an ultrasound machine readily available also hints at the medical preparedness for potentially serious events, even those with unclear origins.
Ultimately, the astronaut’s medical scare, despite extensive investigation and a return to his normal self, remains a mystery. The confluence of a demanding environment, the human body’s intricate workings, and the inherent unknowns of space exploration leaves this particular episode as a fascinating and slightly unsettling chapter in his astronautical journey. The lack of a definitive answer only amplifies the intrigue surrounding what happened during those 20 minutes of silence in orbit.