By John Q. Hosedrinker 
Governor JB Pritzker is set to propose a two-year suspension of tax incentives for data center development, aiming to address growing community concerns about their rapid expansion. This policy shift, detailed in his State of the State and budget address, includes a mandate for state agencies to study the impact of existing data centers on the energy grid, consumers, and the economy. The proposed pause, effective July 1, seeks to ensure the financial sustainability of these centers, protect consumers from rising energy costs, and guarantee a fair allocation of resources, though it requires approval from the Illinois General Assembly. This move aligns with a national trend of increased scrutiny and oversight of data center growth, driven by resident backlash over electricity consumption and costs.
Read the original article here
It appears that Governor JB Pritzker is considering a significant shift in Illinois’ approach to attracting data centers, proposing to suspend the tax incentives that have been offered to these massive tech infrastructure hubs. This move suggests a reevaluation of the benefits these incentives actually provide to the state and its residents.
For quite some time, the prevailing wisdom has been that offering tax breaks to data centers would stimulate economic growth, create jobs, and bring investment to Illinois. However, the sentiment emerging from discussions around this proposal is that this gamble may not have paid off as anticipated, with many feeling that the promised benefits have fallen short.
A common concern is that while data centers require substantial energy and resources, they haven’t necessarily translated into a proportional increase in local employment or a significant boost to community economies. The argument is that these facilities, while technologically advanced, are largely automated and require a relatively small human workforce once construction is complete.
There’s a growing feeling that the significant tax breaks offered to these corporations, some of which are worth trillions, have essentially meant that taxpayers are subsidizing the operational costs of these tech giants. This perspective suggests that the financial burden has shifted from the companies to the general public, particularly when it comes to utility costs.
Indeed, the sheer scale of energy and water consumption by data centers is frequently highlighted. They are now said to use as much power as entire small towns, putting a considerable strain on local infrastructure and driving up utility bills for everyday residents. This has led to calls for more direct taxation or “usage taxes” on data centers to reflect their impact.
Some argue that instead of offering incentives, Illinois should be looking at imposing “tax disincentives” or directly taxing their resource consumption. The idea is to ensure that companies benefiting from Illinois’ resources contribute more directly to the state and local communities that bear the brunt of their operational footprint.
The construction phase of data centers does bring temporary jobs and economic activity, as workers in the construction industry have noted. However, the concern is that this short-term boost doesn’t offset the long-term strain on resources and the limited permanent job creation that follows.
Furthermore, there’s a perspective that in the age of AI and increasing automation, the need for tax incentives for companies that are themselves driving job displacement is questionable. The argument is that if these companies are profiting from technologies that reduce human labor, they should not be receiving taxpayer-funded subsidies.
The environmental impact of data centers is another critical point being raised. Their significant energy consumption often translates to a larger carbon footprint, leading to calls for them to be taxed for their environmental impact and contribution to climate change.
Some observers suggest that the timing of this proposal might be linked to the state’s financial situation. With Illinois facing significant debt and having recently passed a large budget, there’s speculation that the administration is looking for new revenue streams, and reconsidering data center tax incentives could be part of that effort.
The idea that data centers are “necessary hazards” rather than true economic assets is a strong sentiment among some. They are compared to landfills in that they serve a purpose but come with significant drawbacks that are not adequately compensated for by the current incentive structures.
There’s also a call to go beyond just suspending incentives and to actively consider denying permits for new data center construction altogether, or at the very least, implementing stringent regulations and taxes.
The discussion also touches on the evolution of the data center industry. Historically, building a data center meant significant investment in local tech talent and a direct economic benefit to the surrounding area. However, with advancements in technology, the need for physical proximity has diminished, and the economic benefits for local communities are perceived to have shrunk considerably.
Ultimately, the move by Governor Pritzker to propose suspending tax incentives for data centers in Illinois appears to be a response to growing concerns that the state has been giving away too much for too little in return. It signals a potential shift towards prioritizing the needs of residents and local communities over the demands of large tech corporations, at least in this particular sector.