By John Q. Hosedrinker 
Reports have surfaced of Trump administration officers in Minneapolis and surrounding areas stopping U.S. citizens, demanding identification and questioning their citizenship, sparking concerns about potential overreach. One man, Gage Diego Garcia, recounted a six-hour detention after refusing to provide ID, alleging aggressive behavior and threats from officers. The Department of Homeland Security defended these actions, citing the Fourth Amendment’s allowance for “reasonable suspicion,” while critics argue these practices enable racial profiling and violate constitutional rights. Legal experts emphasize that U.S. citizens are not required to provide identification when walking in public, and advise individuals to remain calm and inquire about the reason for the stop.
Read the original article here
Immigration officers around Minneapolis are approaching people and demanding proof that they’re U.S. citizens. This is a situation that’s raising serious questions, and frankly, it feels like we’re navigating some pretty murky legal and ethical waters.
It’s difficult to shake the feeling that this is a direct contradiction of the Fourth Amendment, which protects us from unreasonable searches and seizures. The whole “show me your papers” scenario brings to mind some dark historical examples, doesn’t it? The echoes of the past, specifically the actions of the SS officers demanding papers, are impossible to ignore. It brings up a very unsettling feeling.
Remember when we were taught in school that such requirements were hallmarks of dictatorial regimes, especially the communist ones and even Nazi Germany? That America, in contrast, was founded on the principle of freedom, where you didn’t need permission to live your life. It seems we’re not that country anymore, and it’s something to be concerned about.
The suggestion that we might need to wear some kind of identifier, like a sleeve, to indicate our nationality is alarming. It’s a throwback to the darkest chapters of history, and it’s a chilling thought to even contemplate. The idea that this is being considered or implemented is troubling.
If you feel compelled to carry some sort of identification, perhaps for peace of mind, it’s best to only have a paper copy of it. Don’t carry your actual passport, and definitely don’t rely on a picture on your phone. You don’t want to hand over your unlocked phone to these officers, as they might refuse to return it until they’ve asked their questions.
What you want to do is tell them to “fuck off” and walk away, leaving them with nothing of value. A paper copy has everything they need and is legally sufficient. These officers are not walking around with chip readers and passport scanners, this is not the airport.
You’ll feel most alive exercising your rights by telling some trumped up thug that your rights don’t end when they get pissy. It certainly appears to be an abuse of power. The burden of proof, in any situation like this, should rest with the government.
There’s no law in the United States that states you need to carry identification at all times. And the demand for proof of citizenship has prompted some people to ask if this is truly what we want to become, with the implications of the Gestapo.
It also looks like it’s a precise strategy designed to incite violence.
This is a dangerous path we’re treading. It really feels like an attempt to create a climate of fear and suspicion. It’s hard not to notice that this appears to be a civil rights violation, and the entire country should be opposing this.
There seems to be a strange willingness among some to lose their freedoms. There are those that are hiding behind masks, demanding identification. This kind of attitude is the definition of fascism.
It’s crucial to remember that U.S. citizens are not required to carry documents proving their citizenship, and are not legally required to have their passports, social security cards or birth certificates with them.
If you feel like you would have stood up to the nazis in the 30s and 40s, now’s the time to stand up to ICE.
There are concerns over the media portrayal of these incidents. Some are worried that the media is painting this situation in a positive light, with fear mongering and glossing over what’s happening.
This feels like a blatant civil rights violation.
Where are the so-called conservatives and patriots who champion the Second Amendment, demanding we “show our papers?” It’s not acceptable to ask people to prove their citizenship when they refuse to prove they’re even law enforcement. It feels like we’re entering a period of self defense.