By John Q. Hosedrinker 
Following Russia’s invasion, 510 Ukrainian children were brought to Turkey under the “Childhood Without War” project, where an investigation by Agos and Slidstvo.Info revealed alleged abuse at a hotel in Antalya. The investigation, prompted by a March 2024 inspection, documented instances of abuse and neglect, including two girls who became pregnant due to sexual abuse by hotel staff. Despite these findings, investigations in both Turkey and Ukraine were closed without charges, and the “Childhood Without War” project was terminated. Experts highlight that Turkey, as a signatory to international child protection conventions, has a responsibility to investigate and punish rights violations against children within its borders.
Read the original article here
Ukrainian children displaced by war allegedly abused in Turkey, a truly sickening reality, is something that immediately grabs your attention. Imagine these kids, already bearing the scars of conflict, finally reaching what they hoped was a safe haven, only to face further trauma. It’s almost too much to process, isn’t it? The reports of abuse, the heart-wrenching stories… and then the alleged cover-up, the apparent shutting down of investigations. That’s what really hits home, the thought that those in positions of power may have failed to protect these vulnerable children. The fact that investigations were allegedly stopped and there was no accountability for the horrors experienced by these children is a stark indictment of the situation. It’s hard to fathom how children could give birth without any indictments or consequences.
The question of why these children were sent to Turkey in the first place raises so many questions. Why Turkey? And the response is that Turkey has historically offered to provide refuge in governmental institutions. The situation is complicated because of potential corruption. This whole relocation of children was apparently organized with the involvement of celebrities and various funds. The initial focus on these kids was intense, but it seemed to fade quickly after the publicity died down, a depressingly familiar pattern. There might have been ulterior motives, shady deals involving “otkat” – essentially kickbacks to officials for choosing specific providers. Instead of safety, some claim they were sent to brothels. It’s a dark and disturbing possibility, a betrayal of the most basic human trust.
It is worth noting that there is a heated debate about the role of the Turkish government in this, with accusations of turning a blind eye to abuse or even actively facilitating it. There are allegations that point to certain cultural factors that might contribute to this. However, it’s really important to remember that such horrific acts are not representative of all Turks or any nationality. Every country has its share of bad actors, its moments of darkness. It’s so easy to fall into the trap of broad generalizations, of painting entire groups with the same brush. That can’t be what happens here.
The discussion quickly veers into broader cultural comparisons, with people pointing out that some Western cultures have their own issues. The suggestion is that perhaps there are more significant problems with certain Middle Eastern/Muslim cultures. You see people bringing up child marriages, support for terrorism, the repression of women, the desire for global Islamic rule, and the overwhelming amount of hatred and racism. The fact that the West dominates in innovation, patents, noble prizes, institutions, GDP, productivity, etc., is considered as well. This is a very sensitive issue that can spark outrage very fast.
The counter-arguments suggest that every culture has its share of good and bad people. One person shares their mother’s positive experiences with human rights in Turkey, despite her Middle Eastern background, as an example of this. It’s argued that, in general, Western culture has, over time, made the world a better place. The point is not to condemn or exonerate any group as a whole but to acknowledge the complexity of the situation and the suffering of the children.
In the end, it’s about the children. These Ukrainian children, scarred by war, deserve protection, safety, and justice. Regardless of the details of how it happened and who is to blame, the priority has to be to ensure that such abuse never happens again.