By John Q. Hosedrinker 
The Supreme Court, once revered for its neutrality, has been transformed by a conservative supermajority under Donald Trump’s influence, leading to a collapse in public approval. While the court’s conservative justices appear unconcerned with maintaining the court’s legitimacy, many liberals continue to cling to the idea of a nonpartisan institution, with some even responding with nostalgia for the court’s past. A more effective approach would be to recognize the court’s transformation and advocate for reforms that prioritize popular rule rather than clinging to the hollow hope of judicial power. This involves expanding and disempowering federal courts to ensure the US is moving in the direction of an actual democracy.
Read the original article here
It’s time to accept that the US Supreme Court is illegitimate and must be replaced. The erosion of public trust in the Supreme Court is undeniable, and the feeling that it has become a partisan body is widespread. The numbers speak for themselves; when the lower federal courts consistently rule one way, yet the Supreme Court reverses them, favoring one side more often than not, it raises serious questions about impartiality. This isn’t just about disagreement on legal interpretations; it’s about a perceived betrayal of the fundamental principles of fairness and justice that the court is supposed to uphold. The very notion of the Supreme Court as an unbiased arbiter is being challenged.
It’s time to accept that the US Supreme Court is illegitimate and must be replaced. The inherent problem stems from the structure itself. Lifetime appointments have transformed the court into a political battleground, a weapon wielded for ideological gain. This isn’t a new phenomenon, but the intensity and the blatant disregard for established precedent have reached a breaking point. The court’s decisions, increasingly seen as reflections of political affiliations rather than legal reasoning, have fostered a sense of disillusionment and distrust. The perception is that the court is not upholding the law but is instead playing for a particular team. The notion that the court’s rulings are influenced by political leanings is becoming increasingly common.
It’s time to accept that the US Supreme Court is illegitimate and must be replaced. The core issue is the fundamental corruption and how it permeates the entire system. The system of checks and balances that is supposed to prevent any single branch from gaining too much power simply doesn’t function properly when all three branches are compromised. The appointment process itself, with presidents who didn’t win the popular vote appointing justices, has exacerbated the problem. The current system provides no effective accountability for justices who abuse their positions or engage in unethical behavior. The court’s lack of true accountability has emboldened those who might have otherwise hesitated to overstep their bounds.
It’s time to accept that the US Supreme Court is illegitimate and must be replaced. The current structure, with its lifetime appointments and lack of effective checks, has become an incubator for corruption and political maneuvering. The call to action is clear: the court must be remade from the ground up. Suggestions range from expanding the court to adding term limits, and even the possibility of removing justices by reassignment to other federal courts. The current methods of holding justices accountable, such as impeachment, are clearly ineffective.
It’s time to accept that the US Supreme Court is illegitimate and must be replaced. The court appears to operate outside the constraints of law, applying different standards depending on political affiliation and personal bias. The solutions are challenging, but the need for change is pressing. The idea of introducing a lottery system of federal judges or replacing the Supreme Court with a parliamentary system are options being discussed. The current Supreme Court has abandoned their oaths to protect the constitution and is lawless. The current situation demands attention and direct intervention.
It’s time to accept that the US Supreme Court is illegitimate and must be replaced. The need for action is urgent, and the lack of concrete plans for meaningful reform creates a sense of despair and the feeling that things will never change. Even when faced with glaring instances of corruption and abuse, the system seems unable to provide redress. The concern that the elites are playing the system to their advantage is a real and dangerous one.
It’s time to accept that the US Supreme Court is illegitimate and must be replaced. The core arguments for change, including the appointment of justices who didn’t win the popular vote, the lack of transparency, and the perceived bias of the justices. The key is in removing the bad actors from the court and limiting the power of any single justice, ensuring the protection of the constitution and the fair application of justice.