By John Q. Hosedrinker 
The Diocese of Harrisburg issued an apology after a Catholic school’s Halloween parade float in Pennsylvania included an image resembling the Auschwitz concentration camp gate, bearing the phrase “Arbeit Macht Frei.” Bishop Timothy C. Senior condemned the float, deeming its inclusion of the imagery representing the Holocaust deeply offensive and unacceptable, especially considering the suffering of millions, including six million Jews. The original float design did not include the Holocaust imagery. The diocese expressed sincere apologies to the Jewish community and will review its approval processes to prevent similar incidents.
Read the original article here
Offensive Holocaust imagery on Catholic school’s Halloween float condemned by bishop: It’s hard to know where to begin, really. The news that a Catholic school’s Halloween float featured a replica of the Auschwitz gate, complete with the chilling “Arbeit Macht Frei” inscription, is, to put it mildly, deeply disturbing. It’s the kind of thing that makes you stop and wonder, “What were they thinking?”
Offensive Holocaust imagery on Catholic school’s Halloween float condemned by bishop: One can only imagine the shock and disbelief when people first saw the float. It’s one thing to create a spooky cemetery scene for Halloween; it’s quite another to choose the entrance to a Nazi death camp as your inspiration. The sheer insensitivity is staggering. Even if, and this is a big “if,” those involved were somehow ignorant of the gate’s significance initially, the moment they saw the words “Arbeit Macht Frei,” any semblance of innocence should have vanished.
Offensive Holocaust imagery on Catholic school’s Halloween float condemned by bishop: The context seems to be that they considered the Holocaust “scary,” and therefore, appropriate for Halloween. This is where the whole thing goes from disturbing to almost incomprehensible. The Holocaust wasn’t just “scary”; it was a systematic genocide, the murder of millions, fueled by hate and prejudice. To equate it with ghosts and goblins is not only disrespectful but also trivializes the suffering of so many people.
Offensive Holocaust imagery on Catholic school’s Halloween float condemned by bishop: The bishop’s condemnation is, of course, the right response. But the question is: what now? It’s easy to offer an apology and promise a review of the approval process. However, what concrete actions will be taken? Will there be educational initiatives? Will those responsible be held accountable in any meaningful way?
Offensive Holocaust imagery on Catholic school’s Halloween float condemned by bishop: The artist’s explanation, that the gate represented the “lie” of working towards material possessions, is not a good look. This is especially true because this would not be the first time the church was affiliated with the Nazis. It’s a clumsy attempt to provide a deeper meaning, and does not excuse the choice of imagery, it’s use, or the lack of understanding for context.
Offensive Holocaust imagery on Catholic school’s Halloween float condemned by bishop: The history between the Vatican and the Nazis is a complicated one, to put it kindly. The Vatican signed a treaty with the Nazis and has been accused of helping Nazis escape Europe. This makes the optics of the situation even worse. It’s a reminder of a dark chapter in history and raises questions about the school’s historical awareness.
Offensive Holocaust imagery on Catholic school’s Halloween float condemned by bishop: The article’s reference to “Hell Houses” is another point to consider. These haunted houses use real-life events, including the Holocaust, to shock and promote faith. This raises questions about how the Catholic church views and addresses the Holocaust. The use of this imagery as a scare tactic, to promote faith, is not only disturbing, but also shows the lack of understanding of the Holocaust.
Offensive Holocaust imagery on Catholic school’s Halloween float condemned by bishop: The fact that someone thought it was acceptable to build and display a replica of the Auschwitz gate, complete with its infamous inscription, speaks volumes. Whether it was deliberate antisemitism, ignorance, or a complete lack of understanding, the result is the same: deeply offensive and hurtful.
Offensive Holocaust imagery on Catholic school’s Halloween float condemned by bishop: Regardless of the school’s intent, the float’s message seems to be that the Holocaust is like a ghost, a vampire, or some other make-believe monster. Those responsible for creating this float, and those who approved it, showed a lack of understanding that is completely inexcusable.
Offensive Holocaust imagery on Catholic school’s Halloween float condemned by bishop: It’s hard to understand how anyone could think this was okay, especially given the history. This whole situation is a stark reminder of the importance of education, sensitivity, and respect for the memory of the victims of the Holocaust.