By John Q. Hosedrinker 
On October 26, the General Staff of Ukraine’s Armed Forces announced the liberation of Kucheriv Yar and Sukhetske in Donetsk Oblast, approximately 30 kilometers north of Pokrovsk, over the past ten days. This follows a period of intense fighting and a rapid Russian advance in August, during which Ukrainian forces have since recaptured nine villages. Despite these Ukrainian gains, Russian forces continue offensives, having entered Pokrovsk and accumulated troops there, with reports of ongoing battles within the city. The 7th Corps of Ukraine’s Air Assault Forces confirmed Russian penetration to the railway as of October 20.
Read the original article here
Ukraine retakes two villages in Donetsk Oblast near Dobropillia, and that’s the headline we’re working with. It’s a bit of a mixed bag of news, isn’t it? On one hand, any territorial gain is a positive thing, a small victory in a brutal and ongoing conflict. On the other hand, the context surrounding this news is important, and it’s hard not to feel a certain level of realism tempered with the welcome news.
The General Staff of Ukraine’s Armed Forces announced that Ukrainian forces have liberated two villages, Kucheriv Yar and Sukhetske, located in eastern Donetsk Oblast. These villages sit about 30 kilometers north of Pokrovsk, which is itself an area that has seen intense fighting. The timing is also worth noting; the announcement came on October 26th, and the timeframe for the operation was the preceding ten days.
Now, while any advance is worth celebrating, it’s also clear that this is a relatively small-scale development in the grand scheme of things. The news, itself, seems a bit insignificant when you consider the overall picture of the war, this being a protracted and bloody stalemate. The Kyiv Independent, which is a reputable news source, couldn’t independently verify the claim, which is standard journalistic practice, and something to consider when analyzing the information.
It’s interesting to remember that this area saw a rapid Russian advance just a few months ago, in early August. Russian forces pushed approximately 10 kilometers toward a vital highway connecting Kramatorsk and Dobropillia. Since then, Ukraine has regained control of these nine villages, and also has cleared nine other areas from Russian sabotage groups. That’s a positive, but also illustrates the back-and-forth nature of this war, a reality that has become commonplace.
The emotional response to the news is also interesting. There’s a genuine outpouring of support for Ukraine, a feeling of “Slava Ukraine!” and pride in their resilience. However, there’s also a touch of weary realism. Some commentators suggest that when the Ukrainian General Staff announces the liberation of a few villages, it may be a sign that the larger situation is indeed very serious, and one shouldn’t read too much into it.
The sentiment that “one step forward, two steps back” captures the feeling that this is a slow, grinding conflict. Any gain is hard-fought, and the overall front line is mostly static. There’s a longing for a more decisive breakthrough, a desire to see the Russians pushed back, but there’s an understanding that a full-scale offensive isn’t likely right now.
The question of whether this minor victory is worth the cost is also raised. There’s a worry that Ukrainian soldiers may have paid a heavy price for a relatively small gain, and this is an important ethical question to consider. It’s impossible to know the true cost without full transparency, and those losses can be very difficult to calculate.
The impact on the Russian side is also a subject for speculation. What does it mean for Russian leadership when even a small amount of territory is turned back to zero? Some speculate that it would drive up the internal tensions and infighting within the Russian forces, a potential for more chaos.
Ultimately, the news that Ukraine retakes these two villages near Dobropillia is a small but welcome piece of good news. It shows that Ukrainian forces are still fighting and that they are capable of regaining territory, even if the progress is slow and difficult. The war remains a complex and brutal struggle, and the future remains uncertain.