By John Q. Hosedrinker 
HuffPost relies on its readers to support its commitment to fact-based journalism during a time of widespread misinformation. Reader memberships provide vital funding that strengthens their newsroom and allows them to continue delivering essential, unbiased reporting. The publication is deeply grateful for past support and encourages readers to renew their commitment to help protect truth and democracy. Continued financial backing is crucial for HuffPost to maintain its mission and navigate ongoing challenges.
Read the original article here
Words Of Dictators: The retired Maj. General Randy Manner’s condemnation of the GOP rhetoric surrounding the “No Kings” rallies is a stark reminder of the foundational principles underpinning American democracy. His criticism, particularly his characterization of the language used by Republican leaders as echoing the “words of dictators,” highlights a disturbing trend. The GOP’s framing of these protests, linking them to groups like Hamas and Antifa, as well as painting those who oppose the president as fundamentally anti-American, is a strategic manipulation of public sentiment. This tactic, designed to stifle dissent and demonize political opponents, is not just a matter of political disagreement; it’s a direct assault on the freedoms guaranteed by the First Amendment.
The reaction from General Manner, and the fact that he’s putting himself out there, speaks to the gravity of the situation as he recognizes the inherent danger in such rhetoric. As he notes, the right to protest, to express disagreement with elected officials, and to do so without fear of reprisal, is a cornerstone of American identity. This is why he says, “It’s the first amendment right, and we need to be proud that in the United States we do not at all rule from fear or force.” To have leaders within a major political party actively undermining this right, by falsely associating peaceful demonstrations with violence and foreign adversaries, is a betrayal of their constitutional obligations.
It is particularly striking that Manner, a veteran with a military background and family with a history of military service, takes such a strong stance. This suggests that the concerns are not just political, but that they strike at the heart of what it means to serve and defend this country. The values of liberty, free speech, and the absence of rule by fear or force are not abstract concepts for him; they are principles that he and his family have likely dedicated their lives to upholding. His decision to speak out is not a casual comment; it’s a testament to the profound threat he perceives to the very fabric of American democracy.
The GOP’s strategy here, as General Manner clearly sees, is to create an “us versus them” mentality. This allows them to label any opposition as fundamentally un-American, thus delegitimizing it and making it easier to dismiss legitimate concerns. When political opponents are painted as enemies, the political discourse degrades into a battle for power rather than a discussion of ideas and policies. This type of rhetoric, as Manner points out, is not about governance; it’s about control. It’s about silencing dissent and consolidating power, hallmarks of authoritarian regimes, not democratic ones.
The “No Kings” rallies, as the name suggests, are a symbolic rejection of the notion of absolute power. When Republican leaders condemn these protests, they are essentially taking issue with the fundamental idea of limited government and the right of the people to hold their leaders accountable. This is where Manner’s condemnation of the GOP’s words as those of dictators becomes particularly apt. Dictatorships thrive on the suppression of dissent, the control of information, and the cultivation of fear. The Republican’s actions, at their worst, represent steps in that direction, even if they don’t mean to.
It’s also worth noting that the response from these Republican leaders is just a symptom of a broader issue; it’s a culmination of efforts to discredit opposing viewpoints and to create a culture of fear. By associating protests with extremist groups and foreign adversaries, they are attempting to instill fear in their base, portraying those who disagree with them as enemies of the state. This strategy is dangerous because it can easily lead to the erosion of civil liberties and the suppression of legitimate political discourse.
Furthermore, the willingness of a retired Major General, like Manner, to speak out against this rhetoric is a significant development. It demonstrates that the concerns about the direction of the country are shared across the political spectrum, and even among those who have dedicated their lives to defending the nation. The fact that he is willing to risk his own reputation to voice these concerns speaks to the depth of his conviction.
General Manner’s comments serve as a clarion call. They remind us of the fragility of democracy and the importance of vigilance in its defense. It’s up to all of us to recognize and resist those who seek to undermine the core principles of American democracy, who use fear and force in place of respectful debate and the pursuit of truth. His words are not just a condemnation of GOP rhetoric, they are a call to action. His call to arms is to champion the values of liberty and free speech, and to stand proudly in a nation where power is derived from the consent of the governed, not from fear or force.