By John Q. Hosedrinker 
Amid political turmoil and increasing human rights concerns in the United States, a growing number of American citizens are seeking asylum in Australia. Department of Home Affairs figures reveal at least 29 US citizens applied for humanitarian protection visas between January and July 2025, coinciding with Donald Trump’s second presidential term. While specific reasons for the applications are not disclosed, the Asylum Seeker Resource Centre notes a rise in inquiries, particularly from the LGBTIQ+ community. Although no visas were granted during this period, the applications, which require a “well-founded fear of persecution”, can take considerable time to be finalized, with the outcome dependent on the current political climate.
Read the original article here
At least 29 Americans have sought asylum in Australia since the second Trump presidency began, a fact that, on its face, seems almost inconsequential. We’re talking about a relatively small number, a mere drop in the ocean compared to the vast American population of over 300 million. However, the core question revolves around the potential acceptance rate of these applications.
The complexities of asylum are well-known. Australia, like many nations, adheres to UN protocols, which set a high bar. A key hurdle for asylum seekers is the availability of a “safe haven” within their own country. If such a place exists, the application is likely to be denied. Moreover, the threat of persecution must be specifically directed at the individual, not simply a result of general laws or policies. “Feeling endangered” or “feeling hunted” is not enough to qualify for asylum; the person must be facing documented, targeted persecution. Given these strict requirements, the chances of these Americans being granted asylum are likely to be very slim. It is important to remember that the U.S. is not a war-torn country, therefore it seems improbable that these asylum requests will be approved.
The low numbers may suggest that it’s hardly a matter warranting significant attention. The fact that thousands of Americans are leaving the country by way of permanent residency doesn’t even make headlines. And this is the challenge with this news, is it a story or not? The numbers, at least in their bare state, might not appear alarming on their own. Asylum is typically sought by people fleeing more dire circumstances. Compared to the countries from which Australia usually receives asylum claims, such as India, China, Vietnam, and Indonesia, which have more questionable legal systems and histories of state-level persecution, America is not at war.
However, these figures might be more illustrative of an unsettling trend. While small, the increasing trend does indicate a potential escalation. The perception is that there is a growing fear within the United States, a belief that an authoritarian regime has taken root. This is why the story has legs. If there is any fear within the U.S. of the government, and the citizens require asylum, then that is a story. This is news that any U.S. citizen would need to seek asylum from their own government.
The increasing numbers, albeit small, also reflect a significant percentage of growth. Initially, fewer than five Americans applied for asylum in Australia. Then, the numbers grew to five, seven, and eventually 14 in July. These figures are specific to applications for asylum, distinct from general emigration, and this growth is happening in a country that is a significant distance away from the U.S. Other Western countries, such as Canada, are also seeing this increase, particularly among trans and Spanish-speaking communities. The fear is that this will continue to rise as more Americans feel targeted by the political regime. The question remains, will the U.S. begin restricting people from leaving, as the U.S. hasn’t done in the past?
The motivations behind these asylum requests are varied. Some individuals might be seeking refuge from perceived political persecution. Others may be seeking a more accepting environment, especially those from the LGBTQ+ community. While it is easy to speculate on their individual reasons, the overarching impression is that of individuals escaping a situation they consider untenable, whether that is a direct result of a second Trump presidency or not. However, it is important to note that there are other possible explanations.
The reality is that anyone who can afford plane tickets to Australia likely doesn’t need to seek asylum. Moreover, those who are seeking a better life may find more practical pathways, such as applying for residency rather than claiming asylum. It is also worth considering the potential misuse of the asylum process. Unfortunately, the numbers are a small fraction of the American population. But this may only be the beginning.
One final consideration is that some of the people will be viewed as privileged, as the focus of asylum is often the most vulnerable and disenfranchised members of society. While this is a fair and valid point, it does not negate the fact that there is potential political and social turmoil within the United States.