By John Q. Hosedrinker 
Neil Hopper, a vascular surgeon, received a prison sentence of two years and eight months for insurance fraud and possessing extreme pornography. He had his legs amputated in 2019 after self-inflicting injuries, which he falsely attributed to sepsis in insurance claims totaling over £466,000. The court heard that Hopper had a “sexual interest in amputation” and had purchased videos depicting body mutilations. Despite expressing remorse, the judge noted the exceptionally high level of harm in the pornography, which contributed to his sentencing alongside his fraudulent activities.
Read the original article here
Surgeon admits fraud over amputation of own legs. The first thought that pops to mind, reading about this case, is the sheer audacity of it all. A surgeon, of all people, making his long-held ambition a reality by amputating his own legs? The court heard that this desire went way back. It’s almost a darkly comedic scenario, the kind of thing you’d expect from a fictional show with a twisted premise. But this is real, and the layers of it just get more and more unsettling.
The unsettling aspect is, of course, the potential for this to have extended beyond his own body. A man with a fascination for amputation who also performed countless amputations on his patients. This immediately begs the question: were all these procedures necessary? What was the driving force behind them? This is a case that has roots in something deeply personal and potentially quite disturbing. Court reports suggest his motivations were linked to obsession with removing parts of his own body and a sexual interest in doing so.
It really makes you wonder about the mental state of someone performing countless amputations on patients. It’s disturbing on many levels. The comments I have read suggest the surgeon was disgusted by the perceived “weakness” of his flesh. It’s a sentiment that points to the possibility of an existing condition: Body Integrity Dysmorphic Disorder, or BIDD. The idea of wanting to be a different physical form is a heavy concept. The insurance company suing him is trying to portray his motivations as purely sexual, which could be a tactic to help their case. If it really was a mental illness it would be difficult for them to argue their case.
There’s a strange pattern here, a specific kind of situation. It does feel a bit like the Ice Truck Killer from Dexter. It’s not the first time a surgeon with an amputation fetish has surfaced. I can’t shake the feeling that there’s more to it, more to unpack. There is another type of disorder to consider, Acrotomophilia, the fetish for amputation. There are plenty of people who have it.
The practicalities of this are hard to overlook. This doctor would also have known the challenges amputees face maintaining mobility. And it would be hard to continue as a surgeon, standing for hours at a time, without legs. It’s a scenario that’s just ripe for dark jokes. This reminds me of the “Nip/Tuck” show, I just hope it doesn’t go beyond that.
And it’s in these fringes that the story gets even stranger. There’s mention of the man buying extreme pornography of “body mutilations.” That’s where the story moves firmly into truly horrifying territory. The implications of what that means, the potential for real suffering and violence, is chilling. What did his wife know?
The case has brought some discussion about how and if insurance companies should pay for care. It has been suggested that if he had paid cash, he might have avoided trouble. This would be a result of the medical process, not some kind of criminal act. Even if the person is suffering from Body Dysmorphia, it does create a difficult situation.
There is the issue of the slippery slope. Where do you draw the line? If someone attempts suicide, should insurance cover the costs of care? If someone had a tattoo or piercing and had an infection, should that be covered? Some say the only “fraud” is lying about the cause to the doctors.
The whole thing has a flavor of insanity, psychosexual insanity to be exact. This is something that reminds people of a documentary. The comments I have read recall an interview of a man who had dry ice put in the footwell of his passenger seat, or a woman that used a turkey slicer to try and cut off her own legs. Then we have the case of someone else that self inflicted infections so they could have the operation they wanted.
It’s an unusual situation that highlights how complicated the human mind can be, especially in medical fields. While there are no victims in this case, it is a wild situation. Some patients believe he gave great care. The surgeon has some mental health struggles, just like we all do. The situation is incredibly complex.