By John Q. Hosedrinker 
International study permit issuance in Canada has significantly decreased in the first half of 2024, with a nearly 90,000 drop compared to the previous year. This decline follows the federal government’s introduction of caps on international student visas in early 2024, leading to a reduction in both issued permits and visa applications. Government officials assert that these measures are effective in managing international student intake and are part of a broader strategy to attract top global talent and foster economic growth. The new regulations, which also tightened eligibility for postgraduate work permits, have prompted concerns from colleges and universities regarding their financial stability and operational capabilities.
Read the original article here
International student permits drop in Canada: A Confluence of Concerns and Consequences
The subject of international student permits dropping in Canada has sparked a wave of discussions, reflecting a complex interplay of economic, social, and individual experiences. It’s clear this isn’t just about numbers; it’s about a shift in a system that many feel has gone awry. The consensus seems to be, the shutdown of “scam diploma mills” that have been exploiting the system is a necessary step. Many Canadians, it seems, are in agreement that the influx of international students to subsidize the education system and prop up the housing market created perverse incentives.
Many international students felt misled by the opportunities presented and the pathways available, making them question their move. Add to this the impact on youth unemployment and the downward pressure on wages, and it’s easy to see why the sentiment leans toward a need for change. There’s a palpable sense of frustration directed at corporations that benefited from cheap labor, with a general feeling that it’s “about time” things shifted. However, this shift is causing some disruption, creating a domino effect in some businesses, impacting staffing models.
For those who came here with genuine intentions of studying, the situation presents a mixed bag. Many international students, like a Brazilian student studying at McGill University, still find Canada welcoming and appreciate its diversity. But they also see the negative aspects of how the system has been exploited. The blame is not solely placed on immigrants, but on those who exploited a system based on trust and goodwill, turning it into a tool for financial gain through the sale of worthless degrees.
From a recent Canadian college graduate’s perspective, the prevalence of international students is quite noticeable. While some are genuinely here to study, many, particularly in earlier high school classes, didn’t seem engaged. This created a sense of frustration, especially when considering the government’s slow response to the issue. Many corporations, in turn, are perceived as abusing the system to hire cheap labor. The need for policy change is apparent, particularly when considering the need for infrastructure and housing.
The shift in policy, while welcomed by some, also raises valid concerns. There’s a feeling that the government’s approach might be too drastic, creating unintended consequences. The impact on legitimate educational institutions and their staff is a source of worry. The shift has the potential to destabilize the post-secondary sector, prompting a search for a more sustainable funding model. There is a strong desire to get rid of exploitative elements in the system such as the abuse of Temporary Foreign Worker programs and company sponsorships.
A tangible example emerges from a community in BC, where a local fish and chip shop, which once employed local high school students, now seems to be staffed solely by adult men on student visas. These individuals often work both legally and illegally while “studying.” The hope is that these changes will restore opportunities for young people. Many believe that the post-secondary sector and the private diploma sector have been propped up, and it’s time to settle things down and seek a more sustainable funding model.
Yet, the way this is unfolding has also drawn criticism. The government’s approach is perceived as potentially devastating for the entire post-secondary system, affecting faculties and staff while those who allowed the situation to develop face no repercussions. It is not an easy fix, and the consequences are far reaching.
The reality is that this situation has been brewing for a while. Liberal governments had made changes, but the effects are now being felt across the board. Diploma mills have begun to close down, in response to the new restrictions. The pressure on a system already grappling with social and economic challenges is real. The influx of poorly regulated immigration has created a sense of unease, adding to the existing strains.
For some, the primary concern revolves around immigration and the perception of those who seek to exploit the system to attain permanent residency. There’s a sense that the average Canadian is unable to compete with those willing to accept substandard living conditions. The focus is now on stabilizing the economy and integrating those already here. There is a perceived need for increased regulation to prevent the rise of scams and the exploitation of temporary foreign workers.
There is also a lot of dissatisfaction for the university environment that is being created, particularly at prestigious institutions. Some of the international students are being denied opportunities within these very universities.
The exploitation of the international student system is evident in various forms, including scams and the abuse of visa regulations. These practices are often fueled by corruption and false promises, and the current environment leads to an oversupply of “middle-aged SkipTheDish drivers” instead of opportunities for younger Canadians. There is an increased focus on the need to rework how permanent residency is acquired.
The issue goes deeper than just the number of international students. It’s about the perceived lack of opportunity for Canadians and the exploitation of those from other countries. There is also a concern over how this system has impacted the education system. The fear is that the quality of education is suffering due to the overpopulation of international students in the market.
The impact also affects the ability of Canadians to gain employment. It is not just about the students; it is also about the exploitation of workers. The problems of this situation are not just Canadian.
The focus is clear: to remove the abuses of the system and to welcome those who add genuine value to the country. This is a time for adjustment, and it will take time. It’s hoped the change will create an environment where both international students and Canadians can thrive.