By John Q. Hosedrinker 
White House official Lindsey Halligan, leading a review of the Smithsonian Institution, stated during a Newsmax appearance that discussions about slavery should include “hope and progress.” This comes after Halligan wrote to the Smithsonian Secretary announcing a “comprehensive internal review” of selected museums and exhibitions, prompted by President Trump’s criticism of the Smithsonian as “WOKE.” The review will focus on several museums including the National Museum of American History and the National Museum of African American History and Culture. The Smithsonian responded by affirming its commitment to factual and accurate historical presentations while stating they would continue to collaborate with the White House.
Read the original article here
The White House’s stance on how slavery is being taught is, frankly, astonishing. To suggest that the historical narrative should downplay the negative aspects and focus more on “hope and progress” is not just tone-deaf; it’s a dangerous distortion of history. It’s akin to suggesting the Holocaust should be presented with a silver lining, focusing on the economic opportunities it supposedly created. The very idea is abhorrent, and it raises serious questions about the motivations behind such a narrative shift.
This isn’t just about historical accuracy; it’s about moral clarity. Slavery was a brutal system of oppression that denied human beings their basic rights and dignity. It was built on violence, exploitation, and the dehumanization of an entire race of people. To sanitize this history, to suggest it wasn’t “that bad,” is to disrespect the suffering of millions and to pave the way for a future where such atrocities could be repeated.
The insinuation that focusing too much on the negative aspects of slavery hinders progress is particularly troubling. It suggests that we should ignore the past to move forward, which is the exact opposite of what we should be doing. Understanding the horrors of slavery, the systematic racism that fueled it, and the ongoing legacy of its impact is crucial to addressing the present-day inequalities that persist. It’s not a matter of dwelling on the past; it’s about learning from it and ensuring that history doesn’t repeat itself.
And the fact that this kind of sentiment is coming from the White House – from officials tasked with shaping the nation’s narrative – is deeply concerning. It indicates a willingness to rewrite history to fit a specific political agenda, even if it means sacrificing truth and justice. It’s a clear indication of bigotry and ignorance. It makes you wonder what exactly they are trying to hide by painting such a rosy picture of a horrific past.
The arguments, as they appear to be, seem to imply that the focus should shift towards the “skills” that slaves may have acquired, ignoring the context of forced labor, abuse, and dehumanization. They’re seemingly promoting the idea that slavery was, in some way, beneficial to the enslaved, which is a gross misrepresentation of the historical reality. This is a whitewashing of history, a blatant attempt to rewrite a narrative that is rooted in oppression.
The defense of these statements as “full context” is absurd. No amount of context can justify or mitigate the evils of slavery. The idea that there was any form of “progress” within the system of slavery is a slap in the face to the victims and a distortion of what “progress” means.
It’s hard not to see this as a cynical attempt to appease certain segments of the population. This feels like an open invitation to those who hold racist views. If you’re already trying to undermine voting rights, and downplaying the treatment of the enslaved as something other than horrific, the next step is to defend the old ways. The implications are far-reaching, and the historical revisionism at play here is deeply disturbing.
The parallels being drawn to historical events like the Holocaust are not accidental. They highlight the dangers of historical denial and the ways in which such narratives can be used to normalize and even justify oppressive ideologies. It’s a slippery slope, and the current administration seems to be sliding down it with alarming speed.
This situation is a stark reminder of the importance of critical thinking, historical accuracy, and the vigilance required to protect the truth. It’s a call to action for everyone who values justice, equality, and the fundamental rights of all human beings. It is imperative that such revisionist attempts are met with the appropriate level of condemnation.