By John Q. Hosedrinker 
Reports suggest the U.S. and Russia are considering a “West Bank-style” occupation of Ukraine as a potential solution to end the ongoing war. This proposal would grant Russia economic and military control over occupied Ukrainian territories, mirroring Israel’s control of the West Bank. The plan, reportedly discussed between U.S. and Russian representatives, including former President Trump’s envoy, aims to circumvent the Ukrainian constitution’s limitations on ceding territory without a referendum. Ukrainian President Zelensky has rejected any territorial concessions, but the proposed deal may be put in place.
Read the original article here
US and Russia suggest ‘West Bank-style occupation of Ukraine,’ report says, and honestly, the whole concept is just… mind-boggling. It’s like someone took the worst possible template for conflict resolution, the West Bank situation, and decided, “Hey, let’s try this in Ukraine! What could go wrong?” It’s hard to know where to even begin with how terrible this idea is.
The immediate gut reaction is one of disbelief, bordering on absurdity. The West Bank scenario is a textbook example of a protracted, unresolved conflict. To even suggest applying that model to Ukraine, a nation fighting for its very existence, is a slap in the face to everything Ukraine stands for and a complete disregard for its people’s will. This isn’t some hypothetical, it’s a real suggestion, supposedly being floated around by two of the world’s major powers.
The whole idea stinks of a pre-arranged deal, a backroom arrangement where Ukraine’s voice is conspicuously absent. If the US and Russia are seriously discussing Ukraine’s future without Ukraine at the table, that’s a major red flag. It reeks of the kind of power politics that history has shown us repeatedly fails. It gives off serious Munich Agreement vibes, where other countries decided the fate of Czechoslovakia. We all know how well that worked out.
The implications are staggering. Essentially, this is about carving up Ukraine, establishing a form of control where Russia gets to call the shots, probably with some degree of “autonomy” granted to certain regions. The whole thing looks like a slow-motion annexation, a creeping colonization with all the resentment and instability that goes along with it. We’re talking about an occupation that will inevitably lead to more war, not less.
And the parallels to the West Bank are impossible to ignore. Gradual colonization, land grabs, and perpetual conflict – it’s a recipe for disaster. The West Bank has been a source of ongoing violence and instability for decades. It’s a model of anything but peace. To think this would somehow be a solution in Ukraine is simply delusional, and, frankly, offensive.
The fact that the US is apparently even entertaining this idea is a huge problem. It’s not just about the morality of the situation; it’s about the message it sends to the world. It calls into question the trustworthiness of the US, making other nations wonder if they are allies or future victims. It undermines the global order and emboldens aggressors everywhere.
It’s difficult to shake the feeling that this is all about self-serving interests and political maneuvering. This scenario could be used by someone who’s eager to find a way to make nice with Putin, regardless of the cost to Ukraine. This whole affair stinks of a cynical calculation. Peace prizes are clearly far more valuable than human lives in this scenario.
The lack of Ukraine’s involvement in any peace talks is absurd. Peace talks without the involved party, like Ukraine, are not real peace talks. These are simply two countries making a plan to take over the one not involved in the talks. This entire situation is truly a disgrace.
And what about the people of Ukraine? They’ve made it abundantly clear they want nothing to do with any arrangement that cedes control to Russia. They are fighting for their freedom, their sovereignty, and their right to self-determination. To ignore their will and impose a solution that mirrors the West Bank is to spit in the face of their resistance and their suffering.
Let’s not forget who started this whole mess in the first place. The West Bank conflict is complex. It’s a brutal and complicated situation. It has deep historical roots. But Ukraine didn’t do anything to provoke Russia. They didn’t invade or occupy Russia. To treat them as if they are somehow equally responsible for the conflict, or to suggest a “solution” that mimics the West Bank is simply outrageous.
The whole thing is a clown show. A total farce. And the fact that it’s even being discussed is a testament to how messed up the world has become. It’s a wake-up call, a reminder that even in the face of blatant aggression, some actors will always prioritize their own power and interests above all else.
The bottom line? This is a terrible idea. It’s a dangerous idea. And it’s an insult to the people of Ukraine. Instead of trying to replicate a failed model, the world should be rallying behind Ukraine, giving them the support they need to defend their sovereignty and build a lasting peace, one that they truly deserve.