By John Q. Hosedrinker 
The Ulwaluko rite, a traditional Xhosa circumcision ceremony marking the transition to manhood, concluded in 2025 with 39 deaths. Criticism primarily targets illegal initiation schools where untrained practitioners perform the circumcisions, leading to numerous complications. Authorities, including the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs, have vowed to reduce fatalities by closing schools that violate safety regulations. Despite the decrease from previous years, a concerning number of deaths have occurred due to unsanitary tools and inadequate medical care, emphasizing the need for qualified practitioners and safer practices.
Read the original article here
Mass circumcision ‘initiation ceremony’ kills 39 boys, mutilates dozens in Africa.
The tragedy unfolding is hard to comprehend: a mass circumcision ceremony that has claimed the lives of 39 boys and left dozens more mutilated. The gravity of the situation is compounded by the fact that it happens year after year, a cycle of suffering that seems to persist. The outcry is amplified by the fact that the government seems to have failed to take appropriate measures to deal with the crisis.
The majority of the criticism centers on the unregulated initiation schools, where the lives of young boys are put at risk. Untrained practitioners, sometimes utilizing unsafe equipment, are the source of most of the problems. The shocking statistics bear witness to the lack of basic safety precautions: in one year alone, complications from faulty tools, including the use of old spears and razor blades without proper sanitization, led to the deaths of 93 boys and 11 amputations. Over the past five years, the figures are even more devastating, with a reported 361 fatalities. The scale of this suffering is truly appalling.
The use of the term “Africa” in the headline, without specifying the country, feels like a deliberate act of omission. It’s easy to imagine how much easier it would be to point the finger if the location was specified, as the practice is specific to a particular region. Imagine if it was, “Mass circumcision ‘initiation ceremony’ kills 39 boys in Europe” or “in Asia.” Mass genital mutilation is what it comes down to, and it needs to stop. Everywhere. Period.
The practice of male genital mutilation is often shrouded in cultural and religious justifications, but when these justifications lead to such clear and present danger, they become indefensible. While circumcision might be common in certain cultures, the circumstances described here are extreme. It’s one thing to be circumcised by a medical professional, quite another to be subjected to the brutality of rusty blades and unsterile conditions. If any mutilation is needed, then that requirement needs to come with criminal penalties if it occurs outside of the medical requirement. It’s a stark illustration of how tradition can sometimes trump basic human rights.
The sheer volume of deaths and the use of such crude tools speaks volumes about the lack of oversight and the disregard for the lives of these young boys. The focus on the tradition itself seems to overshadow the very real suffering and the lifelong consequences for the survivors. It’s time to address the root causes of these tragedies and to put the safety and well-being of the children first.
The fact that the specific location is often obscured in the reporting further complicates the issue. It makes it harder to hold those responsible accountable. The details of what constitutes the tradition itself, are in the process, being obfuscated. It would be the same thing if it was a common occurrence in one particular town. The act of mutilation, performed without proper hygiene and by untrained individuals, is a disgrace.
It’s understandable to feel a deep sense of outrage and sadness in response to this situation. If religious rites demand that children be mutilated, then those rites should not be allowed to exist. The choice to undergo circumcision is a personal one, and it should be made by the individual when they are old enough to understand and consent to the procedure.
The fact that the practice persists despite its known dangers is a stark reminder of the power of tradition and the challenges of balancing cultural practices with basic human rights. It’s a complex issue that requires careful consideration and a willingness to confront difficult truths.
It is critical to remember that a child’s rights supersede religious or cultural practices. If these traditions lead to the avoidable deaths and mutilation of children, then they should be stopped. It is important to make sure that practices such as these are performed in a safe, sanitary environment or not at all. It’s time to recognize that these young boys are not expendable and deserve the opportunity to live long, healthy, and intact lives.