By John Q. Hosedrinker 
A federal judge has temporarily blocked top health officials from sharing Medicaid enrollees’ personal data with immigration authorities. The ruling prevents the Department of Homeland Security from accessing Medicaid data in 20 states that sued the administration, along with Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s Department of Health and Human Services from sharing that data with ICE. The judge found that the administration’s use of Medicaid data for immigration enforcement threatened to disrupt the program. This decision comes amidst concerns that ICE’s access to sensitive data could deter immigrants from seeking essential services.
Read the original article here
Judge orders RFK Jr.’s HHS to stop sharing Medicaid info with ICE. So, let’s break this down, shall we? It appears a judge has stepped in to prevent the Department of Health and Human Services, now under the leadership of Robert F. Kennedy Jr., from sharing Medicaid information with Immigration and Customs Enforcement, or ICE. This is a pretty significant development, and it raises some critical questions about the priorities and practices of the current administration, particularly when you consider who’s at the helm of HHS.
This situation is made even more perplexing when you consider the context. HHS, under Kennedy’s direction, has already implemented policies limiting access to several federal health programs, ostensibly based on immigration status. This decision, restricting access to programs like community health centers and Head Start, seems to be an attempt to actively limit services, targeting a specific population. Now, a judge is telling them to *stop* sharing information with ICE, implying that the administration’s actions weren’t always aligned with protecting the privacy of those seeking healthcare. It’s a contrast that doesn’t sit well.
Let’s be real here; the choice of RFK Jr. to head HHS is, to put it mildly, a controversial one. His history of making dangerously unscientific claims is well-documented, and he has played a significant role in undermining trust in the medical community. It’s hard not to feel apprehensive about someone with his track record being in charge of an agency responsible for public health. The man has repeatedly pushed fringe theories, including anti-vaccine rhetoric, conspiracy theories, and claims about the causes of various diseases.
The core problem is that the administration, particularly RFK Jr., seems to be actively sowing distrust in medical science and the medical community. They’re challenging the overwhelming scientific consensus, dismissing research, and giving credence to conspiracy theories and “alternative facts.” This is dangerous during disease outbreaks and times of public health crises, and it goes against the fundamental principle of basing health policies on solid scientific evidence. It’s a trend that seems to be part of a broader effort to defund and erode the independence of public health agencies.
Think about it – this is a president and HHS secretary who are, by all accounts, openly hostile to science, who appear to be trying to create a world of alternative facts where science is wrong and dangerous ideas are given precedence over facts and the well-being of society. This administration seems to be committed to reversing decades of scientific progress. Even as the administration appears to be stripping qualified civil servants of their protections, replacing them with incompetent loyalists. It really is a slap in the face of the hard work and dedication of actual scientists who have worked in the public health arena.
Then there’s the issue of his associations. His alignment with a MAGA agenda that prioritizes deregulation and the fossil fuels industry over environmental protection. The cutting of funding to critical scientific and medical research into diseases that impact millions, if not billions, across the globe. This is a disaster. Kennedy himself has said that no one should take medical advice from him, yet he is heading a department responsible for overseeing the health of millions of Americans.
We also can’t ignore his role in The Children’s Health Defense, the anti-vaccine nonprofit. This played a major role in accelerating the measles outbreak in Samoa that claimed the lives of dozens of children. This type of activism undermines public health initiatives and has potentially deadly consequences.
And the statements he has made. He has said Lyme disease is “highly likely a militarily engineered bioweapon.” He has suggested environmental toxins, including those in drinking water, are linked to gender identity in children. He has reiterated a thoroughly debunked theory that the MMR vaccine causes autism. He’s called the Covid vaccine “the deadliest vaccine ever made.” The man has spread so much disinformation that it’s truly appalling that he has ever been put in a position of power.
The fact that a judge had to intervene to stop HHS from sharing Medicaid information with ICE says a lot. It reveals that the administration’s actions weren’t necessarily aligned with the protection of vulnerable populations. The fact that the administration limited access to federal health programs, but needed a court order to stop the sharing of information, tells us everything we need to know about their real priorities. RFK Jr. is a menace to society.