By John Q. Hosedrinker 
According to the directors of the Oscar-winning documentary *No Other Land*, Palestinian community leader Awdah Hathaleen was killed by a sanctioned Israeli settler in the West Bank. The suspect, Yinon Levi, who was sanctioned by the UK and EU, was reportedly released under house arrest. The killing occurred in front of a community center and was captured on video. The directors of *No Other Land*, which documented the struggle of Masafer Yatta residents, have expressed their grief, and the incident underscores the rise in violence in the West Bank.
Read the original article here
Israeli settler accused of killing a contributor to the Oscar-winning West Bank film “No Other Land” and being placed on house arrest is, frankly, not surprising. The narrative painted by the headlines, and the subsequent reactions, reveal a painful truth about the situation in the West Bank. When you use terms like “settler” to describe the perpetrator, it seems like a softer term than “invader” or “murderer.” It’s a semantic dance that tries to downplay the gravity of the situation. The core problem is an ongoing conflict that has resulted in an environment that is rife with tension and violence.
The tragedy unfolds in the context of the film “No Other Land,” which itself has garnered attention for its unflinching look at the situation in the West Bank. The film, having won an Oscar, offered a platform to raise awareness, and it seems like this act of violence is a direct response to that. The accused, a “settler” (and here we go with that term again), is now under house arrest while those who are mourning the loss of the contributor to the film are being targeted, this seems like a gross injustice.
It’s easy to get lost in the details, but the core message is clear: A Palestinian community leader, who contributed to an Oscar-winning film, was killed by an Israeli settler, and the response from the authorities and the state of Israel is deeply questionable. The response is indicative of a broken system, one that seems to prioritize the interests of certain groups over others. The fact that Palestinian activists were reportedly detained while the accused killer was put under house arrest is infuriating.
The state’s response is to send the IDF, who are nothing more than “cowardly, terrorist, pieces of shit”, to terrorize the mourners. The authorities are not holding the killer accountable, and are therefore sending a very clear message. It is clear that the government is not on the side of justice or equality. You’re left with the unsettling feeling that the system is rigged, and that justice is selective. It is understandable that people feel nothing is being done, and that the entire situation is disheartening.
One cannot help but question what Hollywood, or the entertainment industry in general, can do about this situation. Movies are made for entertainment purposes, but the lack of action of any kind from their side seems to be an unfortunate reality. It’s a sad reminder that the world of entertainment often operates in a different sphere than the harsh realities of political conflict.
However, to say that the Israeli state is like the pioneers of the United States, or any pre-WW2 European nation, is both reductive and inaccurate. The history of the region, is, by far, more complex. The push for independence in the region created a very complex and unique set of circumstances that cannot be compared to a pioneer or a European nation. The cultural shifts that have happened over the last century in the Middle East are enormous.
The reality of the demographics and politics is far more complex. While the political leadership may have certain cultural backgrounds, the Israeli population is composed of diverse backgrounds. The political landscape has shifted dramatically over the years. The right-wing governments in Israel have been shaped by a number of factors, including religious and ethnic considerations. However, the situation is not about colonialism, it is more about a right-wing opportunist that encourages extremist views that do not align with the rest of the world.
The issues with this Israeli government have more to do with the dominance of right-wing religious extremism. However, the issues that have been raised in the news are more than enough for people to be concerned. When we look at how a Palestinian community leader, who contributed to an Oscar-winning film, could be killed by an Israeli settler and the resulting response of the authorities is enough to paint a dark picture of the situation.