By John Q. Hosedrinker 
Environment Agency inspections revealed 199 breaches by 154 farms between 2022 and June, with 141 incidents posing a foreseeable impact on health or the environment. Despite these breaches, only one farmer faced prosecution and one received a fine, while the majority received warnings or advice. A concerning number of farms were found abstracting water without proper licenses, and only a fraction of licenses are being inspected, raising concerns about the lack of deterrent for over-abstraction. Advocates like Wildfish are calling for increased inspections and stricter enforcement to address the issue.
Read the original article here
More than 150 farms in England caught using local water illegally – now that’s a headline that grabs your attention, doesn’t it? It immediately brings up a host of questions. What kind of water are we talking about? Are these farms taking from rivers, lakes, or underground sources? And how much water are we really talking about? Twenty thousand litres a day might sound like a lot, but when you’re irrigating fields, it’s really not that much. It’s like a couple of tanker loads, barely enough to cover a few acres, right? It’s important to understand the scale of this.
Interestingly, there are some potential solutions being considered, with reservoirs mentioned in the discussion. It’s easy to see the potential benefits of having a water supply readily available. However, finding land to build those reservoirs is its own challenge. And what about other options? Could farms consider growing less water-intensive crops? That could be a practical solution depending on the farming operation. It all depends on the specific circumstances.
This situation definitely sparks some interesting debate about farming practices. Some people are suggesting innovative approaches like drip irrigation, inspired by what’s done in places like Israel. This is where water is delivered directly to the plants’ roots, minimizing waste. But, as we’ve seen, that’s not always practical. It seems more suited to certain permanent crops like fruits and nuts, as you wouldn’t want to drive a tractor over the irrigation lines in a wheat field. And of course, the cost of implementing such a system on a large scale is a significant factor.
Then there’s the question of licensing. Legally, farmers can take water, but they need the proper permits, which specify how much they can use without harming the local ecosystem. If a few farmers play by the rules and others don’t, that’s clearly unfair. It also makes you wonder if there are any farmers going above and beyond their allowed quota.
There’s a common sentiment that if something is available for free, everyone should have access, but it’s just not realistic to expect free resources when it comes to commercial operations. Water costs money, and those costs should be addressed responsibly. It makes sense for farmers to pay for the water they use. There is some discussion about whether the water companies are being well managed or are making too much money instead of investing in the system.
Another angle that’s brought up is the impact on food production. Some people argue that the government might be hindering farmers’ ability to actually produce food by putting up these barriers. If farmers can’t get the water they need to grow crops, what’s the result? Some people are concerned about letting crops shrivel up in the fields.
The comments made about fruit production are particularly interesting. There’s a general feeling that European strawberries may not be the same as those in other parts of the world, like the US, but of course, you hear varying opinions on the quality and taste of produce. The UK and Ireland certainly have a knack for growing great strawberries, often helped by climate change and the longer days.
It seems like Jeremy Clarkson might have something to say about all of this in a future season. The show has a real knack for highlighting the challenges faced by farmers and exploring creative solutions. It will be interesting to see how they navigate this issue.
Ultimately, this situation illustrates the complexities of water management and the impact of regulations on the agricultural industry. There are legal aspects to the process, but it also requires finding a balance between environmental concerns, farmer viability, and ensuring a stable food supply. Inspecting properties would be an ideal way to manage and understand how water usage is being used, but that in itself is an undertaking. It all seems like a complex situation with no easy answers.