By John Q. Hosedrinker 
While promoting his “big, beautiful bill,” President Trump faced a significant setback in Congress as Senate Parliamentarian Elizabeth MacDonough struck down key provisions related to Medicaid and public benefits for undocumented immigrants. This decision forced Senate Republicans to revisit the bill and created division among GOP senators, some of whom called for MacDonough’s removal. Despite the challenges, the White House expressed optimism about the bill’s passage before July 4th, while House Republicans, particularly conservatives, threatened to reject the Senate’s version due to concerns over its impact on key priorities and the deficit. Furthermore, more measures in the legislation are still awaiting a ruling from the Parliamentarian, which could create more obstacles.
Read the original article here
Trump Faces MAGA Revolt as Big Beautiful Bill Blows Up Over Medicaid. The whispers of a “MAGA revolt” are circulating, triggered by the proposed cuts to Medicaid, often derisively dubbed the “Big Beautiful Bill.” The idea, as the theory goes, is that Trump’s base, the loyal MAGA faithful, are finally seeing the light and turning against their leader, particularly over a policy that directly impacts their access to crucial healthcare. But, as we see it, the reality is far more complex, and perhaps, much less dramatic.
The labor force participation rate for those aged 65 and older is indeed growing rapidly, and many are dependent on social services, including Medicaid. It’s a sobering thought that some of the most vocal supporters of Trump’s vision might find themselves directly harmed by policies supposedly designed to benefit them. Yet, the claim that this will cause a widespread rebellion feels premature at best. The average MAGA supporter has shown, time and again, an unwavering loyalty, often described as cult-like, and the idea that they’d suddenly abandon their messianic leader over a policy point feels improbable. History and the current trajectory of the “Big Beautiful Bill” suggest that the base will stay, and continue to support Trump regardless of the fallout.
The core of the issue, it seems, is that cuts to Medicaid will disproportionately affect the very people who are most likely to vote Republican. It’s a cruel irony that those living in rural areas, who rely on social services, may be left with fewer options for healthcare. The fear that the nearest hospital could be two hours away underscores the potential for real, tangible harm to be caused by the bill. However, the expectation that this will instantly fracture the MAGA coalition seems to be overly optimistic.
The reaction to this unfolding crisis is revealing. Some point out that Republicans have a history of following Trump’s lead, and it’s a dangerous bet to suggest that they will suddenly defy him. They will likely bend to the will of the leader. This is exacerbated by the fact that some MAGA supporters may not even realize how drastically the bill affects them.
Furthermore, a tax cut for the wealthy and a gutting of social services don’t seem to be winning strategies, and many are calling for a shift in policy. Despite the evidence, the “revolt” is likely a fantasy.
Another point is the reliance on clickbait headlines that promote the idea of a revolt. If Trump’s base were to truly revolt, the impact would be seismic. The base is known for its devotion, and headlines that suggest cracks in that loyalty are likely to be misleading. The consistent message from many is that the base will fall in line; they always do.
It is a sad fact that the people it will affect the most are often the same ones who will support the bill. The rednecks who will get screwed over will not realize it. The current administration is willing to destroy the country to benefit their rich friends. The proposal could severely impact the health and well-being of a large segment of the population, and the irony is that the people who would be most affected are the ones that would suffer and go down with the ship.
The concern is that the cuts are not big enough. And the fact is Trump and the congressman are likely not even aware of the value of the dollar. The value is dropping as the big beautiful bill gets passed. There is a call for tax on large foundations, and the debt to be paid off fairly and completely.
In the end, despite the potential for genuine hardship caused by the proposed cuts, and the clear detrimental effects to those who make up the base, the idea of a genuine revolt feels unlikely. Trump’s ability to rally his base has been repeatedly tested, and each time, the core group of supporters remain steadfast. It’s likely that the bill will pass, and that the political fallout, if any, will be minimal. The whole situation is likely to be a case of a very bad thing happening, but the very people who are hurt will keep voting for the politicians that hurt them. The notion of a widespread MAGA revolt, at least for the time being, seems to be more wishful thinking than a realistic assessment of the current political landscape.