By John Q. Hosedrinker 
Despite President Putin’s public pronouncements of an unshakeable friendship with China, an internal FSB document reveals significant concerns about Chinese espionage targeting Russia’s military secrets, scientific expertise, and even territorial claims. This document details a clandestine intelligence battle, with China actively recruiting Russian scientists, military personnel, and officials, and seeking to exploit Russia’s vulnerability due to the war in Ukraine. The FSB’s counterintelligence efforts focus on mitigating these threats while carefully avoiding public confrontation to maintain the facade of a strong bilateral relationship. The document highlights the delicate balancing act Russia faces, navigating its dependence on China while simultaneously countering its increasingly assertive intelligence operations.
Read the original article here
Russia’s FSB, its primary security service, has reportedly labeled China an “enemy,” a revelation stemming from a leaked report that underscores deep-seated anxieties within the Kremlin. This leaked information paints a picture far removed from the public image of a strong, unbreakable partnership between Moscow and Beijing.
This secret designation reveals a profound level of fear within the Russian leadership. The perceived threat from China appears so significant that it overshadows even the ongoing, costly war in Ukraine. It raises the question: Why would Russia continue to pour its resources into a seemingly unwinnable conflict while simultaneously facing such a substantial threat from its eastern neighbor? The seeming contradiction between the continued commitment to the war effort and the fear of China hints at a deeper, possibly more desperate, situation within Russia.
The fear is entirely understandable, even legitimate. China’s economic and military power poses a credible and substantial threat to Russia, particularly considering Russia’s current weakened state. This weakness is significantly exacerbated by the ongoing war in Ukraine, which is draining Russia’s resources and manpower. The Kremlin’s anxieties are fueled by the very real possibility of China capitalizing on Russia’s vulnerabilities.
The “no limits” partnership between Russia and China seems to be nothing more than a facade. The FSB’s assessment suggests a significant divergence between the public portrayal of their relationship and the reality of the Kremlin’s internal perceptions. This discrepancy highlights a degree of desperation and a potential miscalculation on Russia’s part. The leaked information suggests that Russia might be severely underestimating the threat posed by China, focusing instead on a war in Ukraine that is further weakening the nation.
This internal Russian assessment also throws into sharp relief the geopolitical calculations of China. China’s patience in this situation is remarkable. They are reportedly biding their time, waiting for the opportune moment to assert their dominance. This could involve leveraging Russia’s weakened state post-Ukraine conflict, or even capitalizing on a broader geopolitical shift. The potential for a swift and decisive move by China presents a serious concern, particularly if internal conflicts within Russia erupt.
The supposed leak might be a strategic move by Russia itself. By publicly highlighting the threat posed by China, Russia may be attempting to garner support, or at least understanding, from Western powers. This would allow them to position themselves as a bulwark against Chinese expansion, a role that could potentially garner support or even aid from the West. But this strategy is risky; it would require a significant shift in public perception, something difficult to achieve while actively engaged in a brutal war in Ukraine.
The potential outcomes are numerous, but all paint a bleak picture for Russia. China’s potential actions range from the annexation of territories Russia views as its own, to a complete takeover of the resource-rich eastern region of Siberia. These are not just hypothetical scenarios; they are based on China’s historical claims and Russia’s current state of vulnerability. This inherent vulnerability is amplified by the internal conflicts and uncertainties within Russia, such as disagreements between various factions and internal concerns over Russia’s actual capabilities and strength.
The internal assessment of China as an enemy within the Kremlin further complicates Russia’s already precarious situation. The ongoing war in Ukraine is not only draining Russia’s resources but also revealing internal fault lines and weaknesses. The perception of China as an imminent threat, combined with the challenges in Ukraine, presents a double bind for the Russian government. It’s a situation where the solutions to one problem—the war in Ukraine—only exacerbate another—the looming threat from China. The FSB’s leaked assessment suggests a deep crisis of confidence within the Kremlin, one that could lead to unpredictable and potentially disastrous consequences. It demonstrates that even those at the highest levels of power in Russia see their country trapped in a dire situation, with no easy way out.
Ultimately, the FSB’s labeling of China as an enemy represents more than just a shift in geopolitical alliances; it signifies a potential turning point in a complex and dangerous game of global power. The situation presents not just an opportunity for China but also a significant opportunity for other global players to influence the future balance of power, possibly shaping a new global order.