By John Q. Hosedrinker 
A Canadian citizen and U.S. permanent resident, Johnny Noviello, died while in ICE custody in Miami, Florida, awaiting removal from the United States. Medical staff attempted resuscitation after finding Noviello unresponsive, but he was pronounced dead on Monday. The cause of death is under investigation and a more comprehensive report will be released within 90 days. Noviello, convicted of drug charges in 2023, was facing removal due to his conviction.
Read the original article here
Canadian citizen dies while in U.S. ICE custody in Florida. The news is out, and it’s a story that’s hard to swallow. A Canadian citizen, also a lawful permanent resident of the U.S. since 1991, has died while in ICE custody in Florida. The details, as they emerge, paint a troubling picture. The man served a 12-month sentence for a drug conviction in 2023, and despite having completed his time, ICE decided to detain him. The circumstances surrounding his death are, to put it mildly, suspicious.
The Canadian government’s reaction is something to watch closely. They’ll likely be incredibly concerned, and frankly, they have every right to be. It’s hard to understand why a Canadian citizen, especially one with long-standing ties to the U.S., would be held for an extended period without being granted access to a judge and the possibility of returning home. Many Canadians are likely wondering how this could happen, considering the well-documented history of the Canadian government’s willingness to assist in the repatriation of their citizens.
This situation stinks, to be blunt. The lack of widespread media coverage raises even more questions. You can’t help but wonder how many similar cases go unreported, especially involving citizens of countries without the resources or influence to demand answers. The despair and fear this man must have endured are simply heartbreaking, and the condolences go out to his family. It also evokes the question of who’s behind this.
The timing is also critical. Having served a sentence for a crime, being detained for potential deportation seems excessive and potentially in violation of double jeopardy. The fact that he was already a lawful permanent resident adds another layer of complexity and injustice. It’s hard not to see this as a serious blow to the relationship between the two countries.
There’s the big question as to whether the man would have been sent to Canada or one of those countries that are known to take in those that have been deported. The border states that rely on Canadian tourism dollars should take note. The death of a Canadian citizen in ICE custody could have serious repercussions for international relations, particularly if the details are as alarming as they seem. If a foreign government were to detain and execute a U.S. citizen, what would the U.S. response be? The situation demands a thorough investigation.
The words “dies in ICE custody” feels soft to the truth. It implies he just died. It’s more like “murdered by ICE.” The fact that the man was labeled as an “illegal alien” in the official statement after his death speaks volumes about the dehumanizing tactics employed. The whole thing is a mess that’s going to make a lot of people angry. Canada should be raising hell, and loudly.
It’s understandable to feel skeptical, given the track record of those in power. Transparency appears to be lacking and the damage control is apparent. This tragedy could easily lead to sanctions and further damage to the relationship. Meanwhile, American politicians are out there asking Canadians to spend their money in the US. If Canada issued a travel advisory, who would be surprised?
Even without emotion, this situation is unnecessary. The cost is high, and it erodes trust in law enforcement. The big-picture implications are concerning, and it raises the question of how far this will go. Are they chipping away at the laws?
It’s hard to fathom how anyone can defend these actions. The focus seems to be on punishment, not justice. It’s also frustrating that the narrative may shift toward the man’s pre-existing conditions instead of addressing the core issue. The media coverage has been insufficient, which is a shame.
It’s tough to ignore the history of those in power. The implication is that the end goal of those in power is to have people so scared that they won’t even try to come to this country. If true, this is a horrifying goal.
It further emphasizes why I would not step foot in the US, subjecting myself to ICE. This is just the first. Many in detention are being subjected to cruel and unusual punishment and are being denied medical care and being fed rotten food just for being in this country looking for betterment. The question of whether Canada could pursue legal action against the U.S. government is also a valid one. The rest of the world should be watching closely, perhaps even considering sanctions.
He should have been sent back to Canada, plain and simple. Instead, he was detained, and now he’s dead. This is a direct result of the U.S. government’s practice of paying private prison companies to detain people.
The situation is beyond comprehension. The question remains of where this will lead. Might Canada and NATO invoke Article 5?