By John Q. Hosedrinker 
A recent Channel 12 poll projects a significant shift in Israeli politics, with the opposition bloc led by Naftali Bennett securing 62-72 Knesset seats compared to the governing coalition’s 48. Bennett’s new party is predicted to be the largest, garnering 24 seats, surpassing Netanyahu’s Likud at 22. This potential upset follows internal coalition fracturing, particularly concerning ultra-Orthodox parties, and widespread opposition to their inclusion in future governments. Bennett’s resurgence reflects a broader electorate dissatisfaction with both Netanyahu’s leadership and the centrist alternatives.
Read the original article here
Israel’s political landscape is currently experiencing a seismic shift, with Naftali Bennett’s new party unexpectedly surging in the polls while Benjamin Netanyahu’s coalition teeters on the brink of collapse. The situation is volatile, fueled by internal disagreements within Netanyahu’s government, primarily concerning ultra-Orthodox draft exemptions, and a growing push from the opposition to dissolve the Knesset. This turmoil has created an opening for Bennett, whose political trajectory has been anything but predictable.
Bennett’s past alliances have spanned the political spectrum, making it difficult to definitively label his ideology. While he’s previously campaigned on the right, he’s also demonstrated a capacity for collaboration with left-leaning factions. This flexibility, similar to Netanyahu’s own political pragmatism, makes predicting his future alliances dependent on the composition of a potential future Knesset. The precise balance of power in the Knesset will determine who he needs to appease to form a government, greatly influencing his policy choices.
It’s crucial to acknowledge that despite the current crisis, Netanyahu’s coalition hasn’t technically collapsed yet. However, the possibility of imminent collapse is very real, setting the stage for a potential new election. Interpreting poll data requires caution, especially considering the historical tendency of some polls, like those from Channel 12, to under-represent Netanyahu’s support. These polls frequently underestimate Likud’s strength by several seats, a phenomenon that paradoxically serves to maintain the current coalition’s fragile unity.
The possibility of Netanyahu facing prosecution and imprisonment casts a long shadow over the situation. While he has repeatedly avoided facing justice domestically, the potential for international pressure remains a significant concern. This has sparked passionate opinions, with many hoping for his removal from power and legal accountability for actions viewed as war crimes. Conversely, others voice concerns about a potential shift towards a more hawkish, nationalistic approach under a different leadership.
The potential electoral outcomes are complex and highly uncertain. While some polls currently show Bennett’s party ahead, other sources suggest Netanyahu might still retain a significant advantage. The distribution of seats amongst parties is critical, especially given the unpredictable nature of coalitions in Israeli politics. The involvement of Mansour Abbas’s Ra’am party, a potential kingmaker, adds another layer of complexity. While some believe their participation in a coalition is likely, their inclusion is far from assured and could be a decisive factor in determining who is able to form a government.
The potential implications of a change in leadership extend far beyond the internal political dynamics. The future of negotiations with Palestinians, the handling of the ongoing conflict in Gaza, and Israel’s foreign policy, particularly its relations with the West, are all inextricably linked to the outcome of this political crisis. A change in leadership could significantly impact the trajectory of these crucial issues. Some believe a Bennet-led government might bring a more measured approach to foreign affairs, potentially leading to improved international relations, while simultaneously maintaining a commitment to Israel’s security.
A significant factor influencing the overall political climate is the ideological composition of the Israeli electorate. While a significant portion of the population identifies as secular or traditional, a substantial segment also holds right-wing views. This is particularly true following the October 7th attacks. These trends complicate the prospects of a center-left government forming, highlighting the difficulties in achieving broader consensus. Moreover, the potential for alliances between far-right parties, such as those led by Itamar Ben-Gvir and Bezalel Smotrich, adds a wildcard to the already uncertain situation. Their potential alliance could significantly shift the political landscape, potentially making Ra’am’s participation in a government crucial for either side.
The reliability of various pollsters is a point of ongoing debate. Some have consistently underestimated Netanyahu’s support in the past, while others have proven more accurate. This uncertainty underscores the importance of treating all polling data with appropriate skepticism until the actual election results are known. The intricacies of Israeli politics, with its numerous parties and shifting alliances, makes definitive predictions extremely challenging, highlighting the need for a careful and nuanced approach to understanding the current situation.