By John Q. Hosedrinker 
University of Buffalo graduate Jean-Paul Al-Arab brought his baby onto the commencement stage, violating university rules prohibiting non-graduates from participating. Campus police, already present for security, pursued Al-Arab after he disregarded instructions to leave the stage. While Al-Arab claims he received prior permission, the university maintains he disobeyed multiple directives. Despite the incident, Al-Arab will receive his degree and issued an apology.
Read the original article here
NBC News reported on a University at Buffalo graduate, Mr. Al-Arab, who was chased across the stage by police during his graduation ceremony. He was carrying his baby, whom the university humorously pointed out hadn’t yet earned enough credits for a diploma. The school’s lighthearted response contrasted sharply with the actions of the university police.
The incident sparked considerable debate. Many alumni found the police pursuit excessive and disproportionate to the infraction. The sentiment was that the focus should have been on the celebratory spirit of the day, rather than strict adherence to regulations forbidding infants on stage. Some argued the university missed a golden opportunity for a heartwarming, shareable moment, instead opting for a heavy-handed approach that made the institution appear overly rigid.
Several commenters questioned the necessity of a police chase for such a minor offense. The concern was that the police response overshadowed the graduate’s achievement and portrayed the university in a negative light. Others agreed that the rules were broken, but the reaction was far too extreme, describing the situation as “utterly unreal.” The emphasis was placed on the absurdity of a police chase for an event as benign as a father carrying his baby across a graduation stage.
The narrative surrounding the event highlighted a clash between following rules to the letter and applying common sense. Some viewers noted that the graduate was initially told that bringing the child was acceptable and then told otherwise at the last minute, thus complicating the matter. The argument presented was that the prohibition on infants on stage was intended to maintain order and prevent disruption, not to punish loving parents wanting to share a special moment with their children.
The school’s statement indicated that Mr. Al-Arab ignored multiple instructions and ran from university staff and police. However, reports indicated that the pursuit was brief and officers didn’t make physical contact. Despite this, the act of chasing a graduate carrying a baby across the stage fueled the public’s perception of an overzealous response. Many pointed out that this incident presented an image of the university as petty, and even cartoonish in its handling of the situation.
Concerns were raised about the potential for escalation and the need for a more measured response. The question of whether the university’s security personnel could have handled the situation without involving police officers was brought up repeatedly. A common sentiment was that the officers should have simply observed and intervened only if a genuine safety concern arose. The argument was made that the presence of a police officer, whose duty is typically to prevent crimes rather than manage simple protocol violations, escalated the situation unnecessarily.
Many comments highlighted the potential for a positive PR opportunity that was squandered. The possibility of the university embracing the heartwarming moment was lost due to the strict adherence to the rules and an arguably harsh response. The incident became a “click-bait headline” and the focus shifted from the graduation itself to a police chase involving a father and his child. This sentiment expressed a general disappointment with the handling of the situation and suggested the university could have significantly improved its public image by adopting a more understanding and accommodating approach.
In summary, the situation involving Mr. Al-Arab highlighted a broader debate about the balance between enforcing rules and exercising common sense, and the potential for positive PR opportunities that can be lost through an overly rigid approach. While Mr. Al-Arab’s actions undeniably violated university regulations, the heavy-handed response from university police sparked significant controversy, fueling online discussions about institutional rigidity, the role of law enforcement in such situations, and the importance of prioritizing human moments in celebratory events.