By John Q. Hosedrinker 
The Canadian Association of University Teachers (CAUT) advises its members against non-essential travel to the United States due to increased border scrutiny and reports of Canadians facing difficulties. The warning particularly targets academics from countries with strained U.S. relations, those critical of the Trump administration, and transgender individuals. Concerns exist regarding the potential compromise of sensitive research data during border searches. The CAUT will maintain this advisory until political screening at the border ceases and confidential information is better protected.
Read the original article here
Canadian university teachers are increasingly being advised against travelling to the United States. The reasons cited range from concerns about arbitrary detention to a general sense of unease regarding the current political climate. The potential for unjustified detention seems to be a primary driver of this cautionary advice, with anecdotal evidence suggesting that such apprehensions are not unfounded.
The perceived lack of respect for facts and due process within the United States is another factor contributing to this growing reluctance to travel south. This sentiment is fueled by a sense that established norms and procedures may not apply consistently, leading to an increased risk of arbitrary actions against visitors. The situation is seen as worsening, with certain legal decisions only exacerbating pre-existing concerns.
The implications extend beyond individual travel concerns. Entire university departments are cancelling events and conferences planned in the United States, reflecting a broader institutional shift. This is particularly striking given the traditionally strong academic ties between Canada and the United States, which are now being seriously reconsidered.
The shift is also impacting recruitment strategies. Universities are now increasingly focused on attracting American talent, possibly due to a perception that recruiting Canadian faculty may present undue risk given the travel advisories. This highlights a concerning ripple effect on international academic collaboration.
The overall mood surrounding US travel is characterized by apprehension and even a degree of disbelief. Comparisons to historical periods of political instability are being made, underscoring the seriousness with which this situation is viewed. There is a widespread sense that the current situation within the United States poses a significant risk to Canadian academics, even those accustomed to international travel.
There’s a growing reliance on alternative solutions like hosting conferences virtually, via platforms such as Zoom. This offers a convenient, albeit imperfect, workaround to the risks associated with physical travel. While this shift may mitigate some risks, it also reveals a broader impact on the traditional aspects of academic collaboration and engagement.
The issue touches upon broader political anxieties. Concerns about the rights of ordinary citizens versus the privileged treatment of the wealthy are being voiced. This adds another layer of complexity to the travel advisories, suggesting that the risks are not uniformly distributed across different socioeconomic groups.
The gravity of the situation is reflected in the strongly worded sentiments expressed by many academics. The sheer volume of negative sentiment directed towards the United States suggests a fundamental shift in perception and a growing unwillingness to risk travel for the sake of academic pursuits. This highlights a major disruption of once-fluid academic and professional exchanges between the two countries.
The situation is not simply a matter of isolated incidents; it reflects a broader concern over the overall political and legal landscape of the United States, and the perceived risk it poses to Canadian citizens, regardless of their professional standing. The underlying worry is that the traditional safeguards and protections afforded to international visitors may be unreliable in the current climate.
Ultimately, the warnings against travel to the United States for Canadian university teachers are a reflection of a growing sense of unease and risk assessment. The situation appears to be evolving, with the uncertainty surrounding future travel advisories and the ongoing risks associated with international travel to the United States remaining a significant concern for academics and institutions alike. This cautious approach is a stark departure from previous academic norms and reflects a substantial shift in cross-border relations between Canada and the United States.