By John Q. Hosedrinker 
In response to record-high egg prices, the U.S. Department of Justice’s antitrust division is investigating Cal-Maine Foods, the nation’s largest egg producer. Despite record sales of $1.42 billion in the third quarter—primarily driven by increased egg prices—Cal-Maine’s stock fell after hours following the announcement. The investigation follows a bird flu outbreak that decimated the egg-laying chicken population, contributing to soaring egg prices and increased scrutiny of the company. Cal-Maine is cooperating with the investigation.
Read the original article here
Cal-Maine, the US egg giant, recently announced that its sales nearly doubled in the third quarter of its fiscal year, reaching a staggering $1.42 billion. This dramatic increase, the company explained, was primarily driven by significantly higher egg prices, averaging $4.06 per dozen—a substantial leap from the $2.25 per dozen recorded the previous year.
However, a closer look reveals a potentially concerning disparity. While Cal-Maine’s sales doubled, the number of eggs sold only increased by 10%, reaching a record 331.4 million dozen. This considerable difference immediately raises questions about whether the company might be engaging in price gouging, especially given the significant price increase without a proportional increase in egg production.
The government, it seems, is also taking notice. An investigation into Cal-Maine’s price increases has been launched. The motives behind this investigation are subject to much speculation, with many questioning the timing and the overall effectiveness of such an inquiry given the political climate. Some believe it’s a distraction, a poorly orchestrated attempt to shift blame and divert attention from larger, systemic issues. Others suggest it’s a thinly veiled attempt to consolidate power in the hands of a select few, possibly setting the stage for future manipulation of the market.
The skepticism surrounding this investigation is fueled by several factors. The accusations of price gouging are undeniable; a 70% increase in price with only a 10% increase in production volume strongly suggests that something is amiss. Moreover, there’s a growing perception that government agencies lack the integrity and independence to conduct fair and unbiased investigations, particularly given the recent history of controversial dismissals within these bodies. Some even suggest that the investigation is a mere formality, designed to ultimately lead to the forced sale of Cal-Maine to a powerful entity, further consolidating economic control.
Adding to the intrigue is the puzzling contrast between soaring egg prices and the relatively stable price of chicken meat. Raising meat chickens is a significantly faster process than raising egg-laying hens, resulting in a quicker return on investment. Furthermore, meat chickens are typically slaughtered at a young age, minimizing the risk of illness and reducing the need for costly vaccinations. Egg-laying hens, on the other hand, require a much longer time to reach maturity and become profitable, making them more susceptible to economic fluctuations. This difference in production cycles and profitability could partially explain the price discrepancy, but doesn’t fully justify the monumental difference in price increases.
The arguments against Cal-Maine’s price increases aren’t solely confined to economic analysis. Some contend that the reported “bird flu” is an exaggerated excuse to justify price hikes, potentially used to mask intentional market manipulation. The sheer scale of the price increases, coupled with the relative stability in egg production, lends credence to these claims.
Amidst all the conjecture, the underlying question remains: is this simply a case of corporate greed, or is there something far more sinister at play? The investigation, however flawed it may be perceived, offers a chance—however slim—to shed light on the true causes behind these exorbitant egg prices and the potential implications for the broader economy and the nation’s food security. Whether the investigation will truly uncover the truth or serve as a political tool remains to be seen. But one thing is certain: the price of eggs, once a seemingly trivial concern, has become a potent symbol of much larger, underlying anxieties about the economic and political future of the United States.