By John Q. Hosedrinker 
Chuck Schumer’s belief that the Republican Party will revert to its pre-Trump form is misguided. The “old” Republican Party, exemplified by figures like John McCain and Mitt Romney, no longer exists; it has been supplanted by a MAGA-aligned party that rewards extremism and loyalty to Trump. Republicans who opposed Trump have either left politics or embraced his agenda, demonstrating the party’s complete transformation. A return to traditional Republicanism is unlikely, as the current base actively rewards increasingly extreme behavior.
Read the original article here
Dear Chuck Schumer, the “old” Republican Party is never coming back. This isn’t just about Trump; it’s about a fundamental shift in the Republican electorate and the party’s leadership. The belief that a return to the supposed “good old days” of bipartisan cooperation and moderate Republicanism is a dangerous delusion. It ignores the decades-long trend of the party’s movement toward extremism.
The idea that you and your colleagues could simply wait out the current wave of extremism is naive. The assumption that behind the scenes, Republicans are merely putting on a show for public consumption is wishful thinking. The average Republican voter has embraced these extreme views, and the party benefits immensely from this, regardless of the private opinions of individual politicians. This isn’t a matter of a few bad actors; it’s a systemic issue.
This isn’t a new phenomenon. The Republican Party’s history is littered with instances of actions that should have signaled a complete break from the idea of working with them: from the illegal war in Iraq to the callous indifference to the AIDS crisis under Reagan, and even further back to Nixon’s criminal acts. This isn’t about finding a few “decent” Republicans to work with; it’s about acknowledging the inherent nature of the party. A return to the Eisenhower era, or even further back to Lincoln and Theodore Roosevelt, requires completely erasing a significant portion of the party’s history.
The current political climate is a direct result of decades of Republican maneuvering and strategy. Trump is not an aberration; he is the logical culmination of those actions. To think otherwise is to ignore reality. The Democrats’ approach of civility and decorum has been a complete failure. It has not only failed to influence the Republicans, but arguably it has enabled their behavior. The decades of “taking the high road” have resulted in a conservative Supreme Court, the overturning of Roe v Wade, and Republicans controlling all three branches of government.
The idea that the “old” Democratic Party is also failing is also valid. There’s a need for a stronger opposition party that can effectively combat the rise of fascism, and the complacency shown by some Democratic leaders has clearly made that impossible. Many believe that a complete rewrite of the constitution or even the breakup of the United States itself is a possible outcome. The current system is demonstrably broken, and the Democratic Party needs to adapt and modernize.
A return to centrism to win over moderate voters is not the solution. This is a question of ethics and principles, not just electoral strategy. The path of least resistance and the path of greatest good are not necessarily aligned. The “old” Democratic guard must make way for new leadership that’s equipped to handle the current aggressive political climate. Waiting for things to magically revert is a foolish strategy. The current Republicans aren’t going to become “reasonable” through any form of polite persuasion or gentle pressure.
The notion that the old Republican Party is simply morphing into a new Democratic party is incorrect. The changes are fundamental and far-reaching. A new political party based on common sense and a willingness to confront extremist views is a viable solution. This has to go beyond polite gestures and sternly written letters. It requires a change in approach, including the use of legal and other tactics to combat criminal activity.
The failure to recognize the deeply-entrenched nature of Republican extremism has led to a disastrous situation. The belief that things will simply return to “normal” is naive. It’s time for a fundamental change in strategy. The idea that the Republicans will change their behavior is a fantasy. The Democrats cannot afford to wait around hoping for that to occur. It is not a question of a few bad actors, but of the entire party’s system, culture, and goals. A complete change in approach, including adopting more aggressive strategies, is required. A new generation of leadership, along with new approaches and a fundamental break from the old ways of thinking, are crucial for the future.