By John Q. Hosedrinker 
A tourist submarine, the “Sindbad,” sank off the coast of Egypt, resulting in six deaths, including two children. Nine others sustained injuries, four critically. The incident involved approximately 44 passengers, primarily Russian citizens, on a sightseeing trip. Reports suggest pre-existing mechanical issues and a lack of safety instructions contributed to the tragedy.
Read the original article here
Six people tragically lost their lives, and nine others sustained injuries when a tourist submarine sank off the coast of Egypt. This wasn’t a deep-sea exploration vessel like the ill-fated OceanGate submersible; rather, it was a common type of tourist attraction found in various coastal locations worldwide. These submarines typically operate close to shore, near harbors, offering shallow dives to view coral reefs.
The incident involved a submarine operated by Sindbad Submarines, a company advertising air-conditioned day tours with hotel pickup, guided tours, and dives to a depth of only 25 meters. While these tours usually boast safety features like oxygen masks and emergency evacuation plans, along with support boats and platforms nearby, this particular incident raises serious questions about safety protocols. This specific type of vessel, with a capacity for 44 passengers and two pilots, focuses on shallow-water excursions, making the sinking even more disconcerting.
Although many operators prioritize safety—including comprehensive safety briefings, numbered seating, and rebreathers—the incident underscores the potential risks associated with these excursions, particularly in regions with less stringent safety regulations. One account describes a tour where the advertised “reef” was devoid of marine life, relying on divers feeding fish to attract attention, which highlights a potential prioritization of profit over ecological preservation and genuine tourist experience. This lack of natural interest could inadvertently encourage companies to cut corners to maintain profit margins.
The sinking is not an isolated incident. Egypt has a history of safety concerns regarding tourist-oriented activities, ranging from boat accidents to incidents involving other attractions. Recent years have seen several maritime incidents resulting in fatalities, with some suggesting that investigations haven’t always thoroughly addressed underlying issues. A previous incident involved a tourist boat sinking, resulting in multiple deaths and raising serious concerns about transparency and accountability within the investigation processes.
Many commenters expressed reservations about the safety of tourist submarines, particularly in Egypt. Several individuals recounted personal experiences on similar vessels, some expressing concerns about the apparent lack of attention to safety briefings and the overall condition of the vessel and the surroundings. Some past experiences indicated the presence of safety equipment such as oxygen masks, emergency systems, and nearby support boats; however, the lack of proper training and effective emergency procedures seems to have played a role in the high casualty count.
The low dive depth of the vessel further complicates the situation. While the depth of 25 meters makes this operation less technically challenging, this also implies that escape routes and emergency protocols may not have been as complex or robust as those employed in deep-sea submersibles. In such shallow depths, a rapid and safe emergency surface ascent could have been achievable if appropriate procedures had been in place and followed.
The event has sparked widespread discussions about the safety of tourist submarine operations globally. While many operate safely with a strong emphasis on safety procedures and preparedness, this incident serves as a stark reminder of the inherent risks involved. It underscores the need for rigorous safety standards, comprehensive training programs, and thorough investigations into accidents to prevent future tragedies.
Concerns have been raised regarding the lack of transparency and potential under-reporting of safety incidents. The relative lack of international regulatory oversight of tourist submarine operations in some areas may have exacerbated the risks. The incident highlights the importance of both robust national and international regulations and enhanced collaborative efforts to ensure consistent safety standards across all operations.
The need for independent safety audits and inspections is paramount. Regular assessments of equipment maintenance, crew training, and emergency response plans are crucial for mitigating risks. Moreover, ensuring sufficient insurance coverage for these excursions is vital to compensating victims and their families. This tragic incident should serve as a catalyst for a comprehensive review of safety regulations and procedures within the tourist submarine industry worldwide.