By John Q. Hosedrinker 
In 2020, the arrest of Amaurie Johnson by La Mesa police officer Matthew Dages sparked protests and riots. Following an investigation, Dages was fired and subsequently decertified under a 2021 state law, preventing him from working as an officer in California. This law, intended to enhance police accountability, has resulted in the decertification of nearly 300 officers statewide for various misconduct, though a significant backlog of cases at the California Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training (POST) threatens timely justice. The backlog, stemming from understaffing, risks allowing some officers to evade accountability due to expiring statutes of limitations.
Read the original article here
San Diego officers are among the hundreds of law enforcement personnel across California who have been stripped of their badges under a recently implemented law aimed at increasing accountability for misconduct. This new legislation represents a significant step towards improving police conduct, addressing a long-standing issue of inadequate consequences for officers who violate ethical standards and the law. However, a substantial backlog of cases remains, suggesting that the process of decertification is still far from efficient and complete.
The process of decertification, while promising, also presents challenges. A three-year time limit for investigating and making a decision on these cases could lead to the dismissal of potentially valid complaints due to delays. This presents a crucial limitation that must be addressed to ensure the effective enforcement of the new law. The current system needs to be streamlined to allow for speedier processing of complaints and ensure that the time limit doesn’t hinder proper investigation.
The impact of this law extends beyond just the officers directly affected. The hope is that this new measure will create a more positive environment for the many hard-working and dedicated officers who strive to uphold the law and serve their communities. Their reputation and effectiveness are often negatively impacted by the actions of a small number of bad actors. A system that swiftly removes these “bad apples” should improve morale and trust within the force, creating an atmosphere of accountability and integrity.
However, the problem extends beyond California’s borders. The concern is that officers decertified in California might simply relocate to other states, potentially continuing their misconduct elsewhere. The lack of a national database tracking decertified officers allows these individuals to escape accountability by moving to a new jurisdiction. Creating a comprehensive national system would significantly enhance the effectiveness of efforts to remove problematic officers from the field. This shared database would allow states to quickly identify and disqualify officers with a history of misconduct, regardless of their location.
Furthermore, the issue of accountability touches on various aspects of law enforcement. The lack of robust reporting and investigation mechanisms for misconduct is a significant concern. Thousands of instances of abuse may go unreported or uninvestigated, hindering efforts to identify and remove problematic officers. A more transparent and accessible system is needed, one that empowers individuals to report misconduct easily and ensures prompt, thorough investigations. This, in turn, would improve the reliability of the decertification process.
The current system, while a step in the right direction, falls short of comprehensive reform. Concerns over a potential abuse of the system by a political faction, or the risk of undermining legitimate law enforcement operations, are very real. Balancing the need for accountability with the protection of public safety remains a delicate task. Moving forward, a comprehensive system must address these valid concerns.
The case of Anthony Hair, a San Diego officer who engaged in inappropriate conduct while on duty, highlights the need for stronger mechanisms to deal with misconduct. Hair’s actions, recorded on his body camera, demonstrated a clear violation of his professional duties. Yet, his resignation before a scheduled interrogation suggests that the existing systems may not be sufficiently deterring similar acts. A national database of decertified officers would help prevent similar situations from occurring in other jurisdictions.
The current situation reveals the necessity for broader reforms. A federal push for a national database, coupled with improvements to state-level systems, is crucial. This would prevent officers from escaping accountability simply by relocating. The lack of a nationwide system, along with the challenges of state-level implementations, undermines the overall effectiveness of efforts to increase accountability for misconduct within law enforcement. The current approach, while positive, requires additional steps to ensure comprehensive and effective reform, both at the state and national levels.