By John Q. Hosedrinker 
Contrary to initial reports, the third body repatriated by Hamas in the recent prisoner exchange is not that of Shiri Bibas. This revelation necessitates a renewed search for Bibas’s remains. The ongoing investigation aims to clarify the identity of the deceased individual and continues the difficult process of accounting for all hostages. Further updates regarding the identification of the remains and the search for Bibas are expected.
Read the original article here
The Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) confirmed the horrific news that Ariel and Kfir Bibas, a four-year-old and a ten-month-old, were brutally murdered while held captive by Hamas. This devastating confirmation came after the IDF completed an identification process, utilizing the National Institute of Forensic Medicine and the Israel Police. The sheer brutality of their deaths, assessed by professionals based on intelligence and forensic evidence, is almost incomprehensible. The pain of their family is unfathomable.
The IDF’s statement clearly outlines the heartbreaking details: Ariel and Kfir were murdered in November 2023, a month after they were kidnapped along with their mother, Shiri, and their father, Yarden. Yarden, who was also kidnapped, was thankfully released on February 1st, only to face this agonizing new reality. The revelation that their children were murdered in captivity amplifies the already unimaginable suffering the family must be enduring.
Adding insult to unimaginable injury, Hamas attempted to deceive Israel by providing a third body, claiming it belonged to Shiri Bibas. However, the IDF’s rigorous identification process revealed that this body was not Shiri’s, nor did it match any other known hostage. The body remains unidentified, highlighting the callous disregard for human life and the deliberate deception employed by Hamas. This act is a gross violation of the agreement stipulating the return of all four hostages. The IDF’s clear and unambiguous demand for Shiri’s return, along with all other remaining hostages, underlines the gravity of the situation.
The outrage and disbelief expressed online in response to this news are palpable. The callous disregard shown by Hamas—providing a random body, ostensibly to fulfill the agreement—is a chilling demonstration of their cruelty. The actions taken by Hamas go far beyond standard psychological warfare; they demonstrate a level of inhumanity that shakes the conscience. It’s a blatant act of cruelty intended to inflict maximum pain on a grieving family.
The timeline underscores the severity of the situation. The children’s murder occurred only a month after their abduction. The image of someone living with these innocent babies as prisoners, only to consciously decide to end their lives, is truly horrific. This deliberate act of violence occurred under the guise of a hostage exchange, intensifying the depravity of the situation.
Adding to the horror, Hamas displayed the bodies of the children in a grotesque propaganda spectacle. This staged event, complete with false claims about their deaths and antisemitic imagery, serves only to deepen the outrage and amplify the feeling of helplessness in the face of such depravity. This public display of hatred and blatant disregard for human life is a shocking display of barbarity.
The situation further complicates matters as there are suggestions that a different terrorist group was actually responsible for holding and murdering the children. Intelligence reports indicate that the Bibas family was held by a radical Salafi-jihadist group known as “Lords of the Wilderness.” This group, while operating within Gaza, is not directly affiliated with Hamas. The revelation that another group may have been involved adds another layer of complexity to an already agonizing situation, yet it doesn’t lessen the responsibility of Hamas for failing to uphold the agreement and for the gross deception they perpetrated.
The events surrounding the Bibas family tragedy serve as a stark reminder of the ongoing conflict and the devastating consequences for innocent civilians. The actions of Hamas have ignited widespread condemnation, and rightfully so. The complete disregard for human life and the blatant disregard for agreements are utterly reprehensible. The international community must respond decisively to this egregious violation of humanitarian principles. The demand for Shiri Bibas’s return, along with all other hostages, must be met with immediate and forceful action. The world cannot stand idly by as such atrocities are committed with impunity.